Levard H, Mouro J, Schiffino L, Karayel M, Berthelot G, Dubois F
Service de Chirurgie Générale, Hôpital International de l'Université de Paris.
Ann Chir. 1993;47(6):497-501.
Laparoscopic treatment of small intestinal obstruction is associated with immediate advantages and it may be expected that the recurrence rate will be decreased because of the reduction of wound scars. Between september 1989 and september 1991, 25 patients (16 men and 9 women), mean age 53.8 years, underwent initial laparoscopy for acute small intestinal obstruction. These patients had undergone a total of 43 (1.7 per patient) laparotomies an average of 13 years previously. One patient had never been operated on, 13 had one previous laparotomy, five had two, four had three, and two had four previous laparotomies. Laparoscopic treatment of intestinal obstruction was possible in nine cases including three cases of bands and six cases of adhesions. In sixteen cases, laparoscopy had to be completed by laparotomy, 13 immediately and 3 secondarily. The cause of immediate failure was the impossibility of finding and/or treating the cause in seven instances, four cases of intestinal wounds, on case of intestinal necrosis which required resection, and one case of missed right colonic carcinoma. The cause of secondary failure were incomplete release of adhesions, volvulus, and missed left colonic carcinoma in one case each. Mean hospital stay and postoperative ileus were significantly shorter in the "laparoscopy" group than in the laparoscopy + laparotomy group (p < 0.001). Two complications, with one death, were noted in the laparoscopy + laparotomy group. In conclusion, laparoscopic treatment of intestinal obstruction seems possible but in less than half of cases. Failures are related to the difficulty with which the abdomen may be explored. Laparoscopic treatment should not be pursued in case of problems.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
腹腔镜治疗小肠梗阻具有即时优势,且由于伤口瘢痕减少,预计复发率会降低。1989年9月至1991年9月,25例患者(16例男性和9例女性),平均年龄53.8岁,因急性小肠梗阻接受了初次腹腔镜检查。这些患者平均在13年前共接受了43次(每人1.7次)剖腹手术。1例患者从未接受过手术,13例有过1次剖腹手术,5例有过2次,4例有过3次,2例有过4次剖腹手术。9例肠梗阻患者可行腹腔镜治疗,其中3例为束带,6例为粘连。16例患者中,腹腔镜检查需转为剖腹手术,13例立即转为,3例二次转为。立即失败的原因包括7例无法找到和/或处理病因、4例肠损伤、1例需要切除的肠坏死以及1例漏诊的右结肠癌。二次失败的原因分别为粘连松解不完全、肠扭转和1例漏诊的左结肠癌。“腹腔镜检查”组的平均住院时间和术后肠梗阻时间明显短于腹腔镜检查+剖腹手术组(p<0.001)。腹腔镜检查+剖腹手术组出现2例并发症,1例死亡。总之,腹腔镜治疗肠梗阻似乎可行,但不到半数病例适用。失败与腹部探查困难有关。出现问题时不应采用腹腔镜治疗。(摘要截短至250字)