Walker G T
Becton Dickinson Research Center, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina 27709-2016.
PCR Methods Appl. 1993 Aug;3(1):1-6. doi: 10.1101/gr.3.1.1.
The most attractive feature of SDA is its operation at a single temperature, which removes the need for instrumented temperature cycling as with PCR and the ligase chain reaction. Highly reproducible temperature profiles, over a large array of samples, can burden the accuracy and expense of an amplification technique. However, the expense of a temperature cycler is offset somewhat by the cost of additional enzymes used in isothermal techniques. In comparisons with isothermal, transcription-based techniques, SDA requires fewer enzymes and has a simpler mechanism. SDA may also be more robust than transcription-based processes because it is not susceptible to contaminating ribonuclease activity. This is generally more of a concern when using clinical samples. The most significant disadvantage of SDA is its inability to efficiently amplify long target sequences. Until this short-coming is eliminated, SDA will be assigned to the diagnostic laboratory along with the ligase chain reaction. Currently, SDA cannot compete with PCR in research applications such as the isolation of gene sequences. The second disadvantage of SDA is that it operates at relatively low (nonstringent) temperatures, which produces considerable background reactions. Consequently, SDA reaction products cannot be analyzed routinely by ethidium-stained gel electrophoresis, as is used commonly with PCR, unless the target sample contains a large number of initial targets.
链置换扩增(SDA)最吸引人的特点是它在单一温度下运行,这消除了像聚合酶链反应(PCR)和连接酶链反应那样对仪器控温循环的需求。在大量样本中实现高度可重复的温度曲线,可能会影响扩增技术的准确性并增加成本。然而,等温技术中使用的额外酶的成本在一定程度上抵消了温度循环仪的费用。与基于等温转录的技术相比,SDA所需的酶更少,机制也更简单。SDA可能也比基于转录的过程更稳定,因为它不易受到核糖核酸酶污染活性的影响。在使用临床样本时,这通常是一个更大的问题。SDA最显著的缺点是它无法有效地扩增长的靶序列。在这个缺点被消除之前,SDA将与连接酶链反应一起被分配到诊断实验室。目前,在诸如基因序列分离等研究应用中,SDA无法与PCR竞争。SDA的第二个缺点是它在相对较低(非严格)的温度下运行,这会产生大量的背景反应。因此,除非靶样本包含大量初始靶标,否则SDA反应产物不能像PCR那样通过溴化乙锭染色的凝胶电泳进行常规分析。