Shoemaker W C, Appel P L, Kram H B, Bishop M H, Abraham E
Department of Surgery, King-Drew Medical Center, Los Angeles.
Chest. 1993 Nov;104(5):1529-36. doi: 10.1378/chest.104.5.1529.
Because of the gradual insidious transitions between localized infection, generalized infection, and septic shock, it is difficult to compare data of patients in various stages and to differentiate primary from secondary and tertiary events. The aim of the present study was to describe the sequential pattern of hemodynamic and oxygen transport patterns of survivors and nonsurvivors of septic shock in order to evaluate possible physiologic mechanisms and to provide a template to relate the sequence of physiologic events to biochemical mediators.
A previously described defined protocol was used prospectively to study the sequence of physiologic events using specific criteria to define stages as: (a) early period, the first recorded change in cardiac output; (b) middle period, time of maximal metabolic activity defined as the highest recorded oxygen consumption (VO2); and (c) late period, the time of death or recovery. In addition, three time lines were defined as the first time mean arterial pressure fell below 70 mm Hg, the first time temperature rose above 38 degrees C, and the earliest fall in VO2. Physiologic data were aligned in actual time before or after the time these criteria were met. Invasive hemodynamic and oxygen transport variables were measured with systemic and pulmonary artery catheters; intravascular pressures, arterial and mixed venous gas levels, cardiac output, and derived calculations were made at frequent intervals and keyed to the time of the cardiac output; each set of measurements in turn was keyed to the aforementioned time periods to describe the early, middle, and late periods.
Beginning with increased cardiac index and oxygen delivery (DO2) as the early physiologic changes, there were progressive increases in cardiac index, DO2, and VO2 throughout the early and middle periods. They were maintained above the normal range in the late stage of survivors, but fell in the last 16 h in nonsurvivors. These values were greater in survivors than in nonsurvivors throughout. There were early transient reductions in VO2 that preceded the rise in temperature and the fall in mean arterial pressure (MAP). Although 84 percent of the septic patients were hyperdynamic, there were transient hypodynamic episodes defined as cardiac index of less than 2.5 L/min.m2 in approximately 10 percent of the measurements. There were also transient preterminal hypermetabolic periods in about 8 percent of the nonsurvivors.
We conclude that increased cardiac index and DO2 represent compensations for circulatory inadequacies that limit body metabolism as reflected by VO2. Cardiac index, DO2, and VO2 values of survivors were higher than those of nonsurvivors and normal values. Therapy directed toward increasing cardiac index to supranormal values empirically determined by survivors has been reported to improve outcome. Additional studies to describe temporal relationships of biochemical mediators of these physiologic patterns are needed.
由于局部感染、全身感染和感染性休克之间存在逐渐隐匿的转变过程,因此难以比较不同阶段患者的数据,也难以区分原发性、继发性和三级事件。本研究的目的是描述感染性休克幸存者和非幸存者的血流动力学及氧输送模式的连续变化规律,以评估可能的生理机制,并提供一个模板,将生理事件的顺序与生化介质联系起来。
前瞻性地使用先前描述的既定方案,根据特定标准定义阶段来研究生理事件的顺序:(a)早期,心输出量首次记录到变化;(b)中期,最大代谢活动时间,定义为记录到的最高氧耗量(VO2);(c)晚期,死亡或恢复时间。此外,定义了三条时间线,即平均动脉压首次降至70 mmHg以下、体温首次升至38摄氏度以上以及VO2最早下降的时间。生理数据在达到这些标准的时间之前或之后按实际时间进行整理。使用体动脉和肺动脉导管测量有创血流动力学和氧输送变量;频繁测量血管内压力、动脉和混合静脉血气水平、心输出量,并进行衍生计算,并与心输出量时间相关联;每组测量结果依次与上述时间段相关联,以描述早期、中期和晚期。
作为早期生理变化,心指数和氧输送(DO2)增加,在整个早期和中期,心指数、DO2和VO2逐渐升高。在幸存者的晚期,这些指标维持在正常范围以上,但在非幸存者的最后16小时内下降。在整个过程中,幸存者的这些值高于非幸存者。在体温升高和平均动脉压(MAP)下降之前,VO2有早期短暂降低。尽管84%的脓毒症患者处于高动力状态,但在大约10%的测量中,存在短暂的低动力发作,定义为心指数小于2.5 L/min.m2。在约8%的非幸存者中也存在短暂的临终前高代谢期。
我们得出结论,心指数和DO2增加代表了对循环不足的代偿,循环不足会限制以VO2反映的机体代谢。幸存者的心指数、DO2和VO2值高于非幸存者和正常值。据报道,将心指数提高到幸存者经验性确定的超常值的治疗可改善预后。需要进一步研究来描述这些生理模式的生化介质的时间关系。