Wilcock G K, Surmon D J, Scott M, Boyle M, Mulligan K, Neubauer K A, O'Neill D, Royston V H
Department of Care of the Elderly, Frenchay Hospital, Bristol.
Age Ageing. 1993 Sep;22(5):316-24. doi: 10.1093/ageing/22.5.316.
Seventy-nine patients with probable Alzheimer's disease were enrolled into a double-blind, placebo-controlled cross-over study to assess the therapeutic effect and safety of THA (tetrahydroaminoacridine; tacrine) without concomitant lecithin administration. Forty-one patients completed the trial which consisted of two 12-week treatment phases separated by a 4-week wash-out period. Twenty-six subjects were withdrawn during the active treatment phase, mostly because of elevated transaminases or cholinergic side-effects, and ten during treatment with placebo. Statistical analyses were conducted on two groups of patients; those completing the cross-over and those with at least one evaluation in the first treatment period. This latter analysis, using the last observation carried forward was used to approximate an intention-to-treat analysis. THA was favoured over placebo in all three primary outcome measures (MMSE, ADAS Non-cognitive Scale, and the Functional Life Scale), but the results did not reach statistical significance. THA was favoured over placebo in five of the seven secondary outcome measures, but for only two of these was statistical significance attained. In terms of a three-point or greater increase in MMSE score, three to four times as many subjects improved on THA as on placebo.
79名疑似患有阿尔茨海默病的患者被纳入一项双盲、安慰剂对照的交叉研究,以评估在不联用卵磷脂的情况下他克林(四氢氨基吖啶)的治疗效果和安全性。41名患者完成了该试验,试验包括两个为期12周的治疗阶段,中间有4周的洗脱期。26名受试者在积极治疗阶段退出,主要原因是转氨酶升高或胆碱能副作用,10名受试者在接受安慰剂治疗期间退出。对两组患者进行了统计分析;一组是完成交叉试验的患者,另一组是在第一个治疗期至少有一次评估的患者。后一种分析采用末次观察结转法,以近似意向性分析。在所有三项主要结局指标(简易精神状态检查表、阿尔茨海默病评估量表非认知量表和功能生活量表)上,他克林均优于安慰剂,但结果未达到统计学显著性。在七项次要结局指标中的五项上,他克林优于安慰剂,但其中只有两项达到统计学显著性。就简易精神状态检查表评分提高三分或更多而言,使用他克林治疗后症状改善的受试者数量是使用安慰剂的三到四倍。