Warner D S, McFarlane C, Todd M M, Ludwig P, McAllister A M
Department of Anesthesia, University of Iowa, Iowa City 52242.
Anesthesiology. 1993 Nov;79(5):985-92. doi: 10.1097/00000542-199311000-00017.
There has been little systematic examination concerning the comparative effects of the anesthetized versus the awake state on outcome from cerebral ischemia. This experiment evaluated infarct volume and neurologic function in rats subjected to temporary focal ischemia while anesthetized with either sevoflurane or halothane. Outcome in these animals was compared to that observed in rats maintained unanesthetized during a similar ischemic insult.
All rats were anesthetized with halothane and surgically prepared for filament occlusion of the middle cerebral artery. After preparation, one group (Halothane) remained anesthetized with approximately 1.4 MAC halothane. In another group (Sevoflurane), halothane was discontinued and substituted with sevoflurane, which was administered until electroencephalographic burst suppression was evident (approximately 1.4 MAC). The final group (Awake) was allowed to awaken immediately after the onset of ischemia. Middle cerebral artery occlusion persisted for 90 min in all groups. The middle cerebral artery filament then was removed, and a 96-h survival interval was allowed. Neurologic function and infarct volume were determined. Recent evidence indicates that transient mild hyperthermia occurs in awake rats undergoing filament occlusion of the middle cerebral artery. To examine the potential role of mild hyperthermia in this experiment, a second experiment was performed in which rats anesthetized with halothane underwent 90-min focal ischemia, with pericranial temperatures held at either 38.0 degrees C or 39.2 degrees C.
Intraischemic mean arterial pressure was 20-25 mmHg lower in the two anesthetized groups compared with awake animals. Despite this finding, cortical infarct volumes (mean +/- SD; Halothane, 17 +/- 32 mm3; Sevoflurane, 36 +/- 57 mm3; Awake, 115 +/- 104 mm3; Sevoflurane, 36 +/- 57 mm3; Awake, 115 +/- 104 mm3) and subcortical infarct volumes (mean +/- SD; Halothane, 39 +/- 57 mm3; Sevoflurane, 50 +/- 29 mm3; Awake, 88 +/- 46 mm3) were reduced in both groups of anesthetized rats. This reduction correlated with improved neurologic function. The rats in whom the pericranial temperature was maintained at 39.2 degrees C had a larger total infarct volume (218 +/- 81 mm3) and increased neurologic deficits when compared to those in whom the pericranial temperature was maintained at 38.0 degrees C (total infarct volume, 75 +/- 77 mm3).
Both halothane and sevoflurane substantially reduced damage in this focal ischemia model when compared to outcome resulting from the same insult induced in awake rats. The reduction in intraischemic mean arterial pressure caused by the anesthetics did not seem contributory to outcome. Brain temperature differences among the groups were not defined. Because small differences in pericranial temperature were shown to have major effects on outcome, further work is required to determine if differences in brain temperature explain the observed protective effects of these anesthetics.
关于麻醉状态与清醒状态对脑缺血预后的比较影响,几乎没有系统的研究。本实验评估了用七氟醚或氟烷麻醉的大鼠在短暂局灶性脑缺血时的梗死体积和神经功能。将这些动物的预后与在类似缺血性损伤期间未麻醉的大鼠的预后进行比较。
所有大鼠用氟烷麻醉,并通过手术准备进行大脑中动脉线栓法闭塞。准备完成后,一组(氟烷组)继续用约1.4倍最低肺泡有效浓度(MAC)的氟烷麻醉。另一组(七氟醚组)停用氟烷,改用七氟醚,持续给药直至脑电图出现爆发抑制(约1.4 MAC)。最后一组(清醒组)在缺血开始后立即使其苏醒。所有组大脑中动脉闭塞持续90分钟。然后移除大脑中动脉线栓,并给予96小时的存活期。测定神经功能和梗死体积。最近的证据表明,在接受大脑中动脉线栓法闭塞的清醒大鼠中会出现短暂性轻度体温过高。为了研究轻度体温过高在本实验中的潜在作用,进行了第二项实验,其中用氟烷麻醉的大鼠接受90分钟的局灶性脑缺血,颅周温度保持在38.0℃或39.2℃。
与清醒动物相比,两个麻醉组的缺血期间平均动脉压低20 - 25 mmHg。尽管有此发现,但两个麻醉组的皮质梗死体积(平均值±标准差;氟烷组,17±32 mm³;七氟醚组,36±57 mm³;清醒组,115±104 mm³;七氟醚组,36±57 mm³;清醒组,115±104 mm³)和皮质下梗死体积(平均值±标准差;氟烷组,39±57 mm³;七氟醚组,50±29 mm³;清醒组,88±46 mm³)均减小。这种减小与神经功能改善相关。与颅周温度保持在38.0℃的大鼠(总梗死体积,75±77 mm³)相比,颅周温度保持在39.2℃的大鼠总梗死体积更大(218±81 mm³)且神经功能缺损增加。
与清醒大鼠遭受相同损伤所导致的预后相比,氟烷和七氟醚在这个局灶性缺血模型中均显著减少了损伤。麻醉剂引起的缺血期间平均动脉压降低似乎对预后没有影响。各实验组间的脑温差异未明确。由于颅周温度的微小差异显示对预后有重大影响,因此需要进一步研究以确定脑温差异是否能解释这些麻醉剂所观察到的保护作用。