Lurie K G, Dutton J, Mangat R, Newman D, Eisenberg S, Scheinman M
Department of Medicine, University of California, San Francisco.
Am J Cardiol. 1993 Dec 1;72(17):1286-90. doi: 10.1016/0002-9149(93)90298-q.
Vasovagal syncope after head-up tilting is thought to be secondary to a complex, neurally-mediated reflex with both vasodepressor and cardioinhibitory efferent components. The efficacy of edrophonium, an acetylcholinesterase inhibitor, as a provocative agent for triggering syncope during head-up tilt testing was evaluated. Forty-five consecutive patients (22 female and 23 male) with history of recurrent unexplained syncope received edrophonium (10 mg intravenous) after 30 minutes of 60 degrees head-up tilting alone. Twenty normal control subjects (9 female and 11 male) were tested with head-up tilt testing and edrophonium. Syncope was induced in 19 of 45 patients with the diagnosis of unexplained syncope. In 9 patients who developed syncope with head-up tilting alone, the predominant hemodynamic finding was marked vasodepression. In contrast, in 10 patients who developed syncope only after head-up tilting and edrophonium, the predominant hemodynamic findings were marked vasodepression and bradycardia. Syncope was induced in 1 of 20 normal subjects after head-up tilting and edrophonium. There was no long-term complication from using edrophonium. It is concluded that head-up tilt testing with edrophonium: (1) significantly increases the identification of patients with vasovagal syncope, (2) may be particularly useful when provocation with isoproterenol is undesirable, and (3) may be an effective method to help differentiate patients with a significant reflex cardioinhibitory component from those with a predominantly reflex vasodepressor component.
头高位倾斜试验后发生的血管迷走性晕厥被认为是继发于一种复杂的、神经介导的反射,该反射具有血管减压和心脏抑制传出成分。评估了乙酰胆碱酯酶抑制剂依酚氯铵作为头高位倾斜试验期间诱发晕厥的激发剂的疗效。45例有不明原因复发性晕厥病史的连续患者(22例女性和23例男性)在单独进行60度头高位倾斜30分钟后接受依酚氯铵(静脉注射10mg)。20名正常对照者(9例女性和11例男性)接受头高位倾斜试验和依酚氯铵检测。45例不明原因晕厥患者中有19例诱发了晕厥。在9例仅通过头高位倾斜就发生晕厥的患者中,主要的血流动力学表现是明显的血管减压。相比之下,在10例仅在头高位倾斜和依酚氯铵后才发生晕厥的患者中,主要的血流动力学表现是明显的血管减压和心动过缓。20名正常受试者中有1例在头高位倾斜和依酚氯铵后诱发了晕厥。使用依酚氯铵没有长期并发症。结论是,头高位倾斜试验联合依酚氯铵:(1)显著提高了血管迷走性晕厥患者的识别率,(2)在不适合使用异丙肾上腺素激发试验时可能特别有用,(3)可能是一种有助于区分有明显反射性心脏抑制成分的患者和主要有反射性血管减压成分的患者的有效方法。