Hildebolt C F, Rupich R C, Vannier M W, Zerbolio D J, Shrout M K, Cohen S, Pinkas A
Mallinckrodt Institute of Radiology, Washington University, St. Louis, MO 63110.
J Clin Periodontol. 1993 Nov;20(10):739-45. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-051x.1993.tb00700.x.
In vitro periodontal alveolar bone mineral content (BMC) measurements obtained with dual-energy radiography (DER) were compared with assessments based on bitewing radiographs (BWX). In addition, in patients, the relationship between bitewing and several postcranial dual-energy-radiographic measures were evaluated. Dual-energy-radiographic and bitewing measurements were made on 2 cadaver mandibles initially and after 2 incremental bone reductions at 4 sites. Rank-order correlations between dual-energy-radiographic and bitewing measures for the 4 sites ranged from 0.7 to 1.00. Bitewing measures indicated true bone loss with a sensitivity of 1.00. For patients, correlations between bitewing measures and dual-energy-radiographic scans suggested the strongest relationships were in the distal sections of the radius and ulna and in the intertrochanteric and Ward's areas of the femur. Correlations, in the 0.5-0.6 range, were not statistically significant (p > 0.05), but were quite robust considering the small sample size and preliminary nature of this investigation. Results suggest that the bitewing measure is sufficiently sensitive to detect clinically meaningful (5% or greater) changes in alveolar BMC and, further, that alveolar bone mineral content may reflect postcranial BMC. The implications of postcranial bone mineral changes being reflected in alveolar bone would enhance both our understanding and treatment of alveolar bone loss. The use of bitewing measures to facilitate identification of patients with postcranial bone loss is discussed.
将通过双能X线摄影(DER)获得的体外牙周牙槽骨矿物质含量(BMC)测量结果与基于咬合翼片X线照片(BWX)的评估进行比较。此外,还评估了患者咬合翼片与几种颅后双能X线测量指标之间的关系。最初在2具尸体下颌骨上以及在4个部位进行2次递增性骨量减少后,进行了双能X线摄影和咬合翼片测量。4个部位双能X线摄影和咬合翼片测量之间的等级相关性在0.7至1.00之间。咬合翼片测量显示真正的骨质流失,敏感性为1.00。对于患者,咬合翼片测量与双能X线扫描之间的相关性表明,最强的关系存在于桡骨和尺骨的远端以及股骨的转子间和沃德区域。在0.5 - 0.6范围内的相关性无统计学意义(p > 0.05),但考虑到本研究样本量小和初步性质,相关性相当显著。结果表明,咬合翼片测量对检测牙槽骨BMC临床上有意义的(5%或更大)变化足够敏感,而且牙槽骨矿物质含量可能反映颅后骨矿物质含量。牙槽骨反映颅后骨矿物质变化的意义将增强我们对牙槽骨丢失的理解和治疗。还讨论了使用咬合翼片测量来帮助识别颅后骨质流失患者的问题。