Bruton C J, Stevens J R, Frith C D
MRC Department of Neuropathology, Runwell Hospital, Wickford, UK.
Neurology. 1994 Jan;44(1):34-42. doi: 10.1212/wnl.44.1.34.
This study examines the relationship between epilepsy and psychosis. It compares clinical, EEG, and neuropathologic data from a group of subjects who had both epilepsy and psychosis with similar information from another group of patients who had epilepsy but no evidence of psychotic illness. We examined, blind to clinical diagnosis, gross and microscopic material from whole-brain specimens from 10 patients diagnosed with epilepsy plus schizophrenia-like psychosis, nine subjects diagnosed with epilepsy plus "epileptic psychosis," and 36 individuals with epilepsy (21 from an epileptic colony and 15 from the community at large) who had no history of psychosis (n = 10 + 9 + 21 + 15 = 55). We abstracted case histories without knowledge of pathologic findings. Epileptic colony patients had an earlier age at onset of seizures, while epileptic colony and epileptic psychosis patients had more frequent seizures. Epileptic individuals in the community died at a younger age than did epileptic patients in long-stay hospital care. Psychotic epileptic patients had larger cerebral ventricles, excess periventricular gliosis, and more focal cerebral damage compared with epileptic patients who had no psychotic illness. Epileptic patients with schizophrenia-like psychosis were distinguished from all other groups by a significant excess of pinpoint perivascular white-matter softenings. We found that mesial temporal sclerosis and temporal lobe epilepsy occurred with equal frequency in the psychotic and nonpsychotic groups; generalized seizures occurred more frequently in the psychotic epileptics and the epileptic colony epileptics than in the community epileptic controls.
本研究探讨癫痫与精神病之间的关系。它将一组既有癫痫又有精神病的受试者的临床、脑电图和神经病理学数据,与另一组有癫痫但无精神病证据的患者的类似信息进行了比较。我们在对临床诊断不知情的情况下,检查了10例被诊断为癫痫加精神分裂症样精神病患者、9例被诊断为癫痫加“癫痫性精神病”患者以及36例无精神病病史的癫痫患者(21例来自癫痫患者聚居地,15例来自普通社区)(n = 10 + 9 + 21 + 15 = 55)全脑标本的大体和微观材料。我们在不知道病理结果的情况下提取了病史。癫痫患者聚居地的患者癫痫发作起始年龄较早,而癫痫患者聚居地和癫痫性精神病患者的癫痫发作更为频繁。社区中的癫痫患者比长期住院治疗的癫痫患者死亡年龄更小。与无精神病的癫痫患者相比,患有精神病的癫痫患者脑室更大、脑室周围胶质增生过多且局灶性脑损伤更多。患有精神分裂症样精神病的癫痫患者与所有其他组的区别在于,其血管周围白质点状软化明显过多。我们发现,内侧颞叶硬化和颞叶癫痫在患有精神病和未患精神病的两组中出现频率相同;全身性发作在患有精神病的癫痫患者和癫痫患者聚居地的癫痫患者中比在社区癫痫对照组中更为频繁。