Pennell D J, Mavrogeni S, Anagnostopoulos C, Ell P J, Underwood S R
Nuclear Medicine Department, Royal Brompton National Heart and Lung Hospital, London, UK.
Nucl Med Commun. 1993 Nov;14(11):939-45. doi: 10.1097/00006231-199311000-00002.
Exercise thallium imaging is effective and provides information on exercise tolerance and symptoms, but is less sensitive if exercise is submaximal. When dipyridamole alone is used for such patients, the exercise parameters are lost and high background uptake results. This study examines dipyridamole combined with maximal exercise, to capitalize on the strengths of both techniques. Thallium tomography was performed in 122 patients with dipyridamole (group 1), exercise (group 2), or dipyridamole with maximum exercise (group 3). In patients with coronary artery disease, thallium tomography was abnormal in 92, 93 and 95% (P = ns), with reversible ischaemia in 82, 81 and 84% (P = ns) in the three groups, respectively. Among patients in groups 2 and 3 who exercised submaximally, detection of individual arterial stenoses was improved in group 3 (P < 0.05) and larger defects were found (2.4 versus 4.2 segments, P < 0.01). In group 3, no serious complications occurred and fewer vasodilatory side effects were seen than in group 1 (P < 0.01). The heart to splanchnic count ratio in groups 2 and 3 (1.61 versus 1.65, P = ns) was significantly greater than in group 1 (1.28, P < 0.0001). Compared with exercise alone, additional dipyridamole improved diagnostic accuracy in patients with limited exercise potential. Compared with dipyridamole alone, additional exercise provided useful exercise information, reduced vasodilatory side effects and improved scan quality. Combined dipyridamole and exercise stress is safe, and could be used routinely, but a larger study is required to establish if there is an overall diagnostic improvement.
运动铊显像有效,可提供运动耐量和症状方面的信息,但如果运动未达最大负荷则敏感性较低。对于此类患者单独使用双嘧达莫时,会丢失运动参数并导致高本底摄取。本研究探讨双嘧达莫联合最大运动,以利用两种技术的优势。对122例患者进行了铊断层扫描,分别为双嘧达莫组(第1组)、运动组(第2组)或双嘧达莫加最大运动组(第3组)。在冠心病患者中,铊断层扫描异常率在三组中分别为92%、93%和95%(P=无显著性差异),可逆性缺血率分别为82%、81%和84%(P=无显著性差异)。在第2组和第3组中运动未达最大负荷的患者中,第3组对单个动脉狭窄的检测有所改善(P<0.05),且发现的缺损更大(2.4节段对4.2节段,P<0.01)。在第3组中,未发生严重并发症,且与第1组相比,血管扩张副作用较少(P<0.01)。第2组和第3组的心脏与内脏计数比(1.61对1.65,P=无显著性差异)显著高于第1组(1.28,P<0.0001)。与单纯运动相比,额外使用双嘧达莫提高了运动潜力有限患者的诊断准确性。与单独使用双嘧达莫相比,额外运动提供了有用的运动信息减少了血管扩张副作用并改善了扫描质量。双嘧达莫与运动应激联合使用是安全的,可常规应用,但需要更大规模的研究来确定是否有整体诊断改善。