Denyer S K, Gibson G
Department of Public Health Medicine, Nurses' Home, Sunderland District General Hospital.
Public Health. 1993 Nov;107(6):451-7. doi: 10.1016/s0033-3506(05)80171-4.
To investigate the apparently poor access of one district's residents to plastic surgery services.
Retrospective study of age-standardised operation rates for the year 1991-92. Operation rates were taken as a proxy measure for access.
Sunderland District Health Authority, and Durham District Health Authority.
Operation rates for surgical specialties in the two districts.
There were considerable differences in the operation rates for plastic surgery between districts in the Region. Detailed analysis of two districts revealed a significant difference between the two (Sunderland 2.25/1,000; Durham 4.24/1,000, P < 0.001). Sixteen diagnoses were identified as contributing to this difference. However, when these diagnoses were examined across all surgical specialties, the difference in operation rates virtually disappeared (Sunderland 6/1,000; Durham 6.16/1,000).
Sunderland residents were far more likely to have 'plastic' cases treated by other than plastic surgery specialists, which reflects the balance and expertise of specialties in the district. The need for plastic surgery services will be affected by the local interest and expertise. Operation rates should not be used on their own to indicate inequity in access.
调查某地区居民明显难以获得整形手术服务的情况。
对1991 - 1992年年龄标准化手术率进行回顾性研究。手术率被用作衡量可及性的替代指标。
桑德兰地区卫生局和达勒姆地区卫生局。
两个地区外科专科的手术率。
该地区不同地区之间整形手术的手术率存在显著差异。对两个地区的详细分析显示两者之间存在显著差异(桑德兰2.25/1000;达勒姆4.24/1000,P < 0.001)。确定了16种诊断导致了这种差异。然而,当在所有外科专科中检查这些诊断时,手术率的差异几乎消失了(桑德兰6/1000;达勒姆6.16/1000)。
桑德兰居民的“整形”病例由非整形手术专科医生治疗的可能性要大得多,这反映了该地区专科的平衡和专业水平。整形手术服务的需求将受到当地兴趣和专业知识的影响。手术率不应单独用于表明可及性方面的不公平。