Dörr Zegers O
Rev Med Chil. 1993 Jul;121(7):811-8.
The historical reasons for the importance of ethical issues in medicine are revisited. An analysis of doctor-patient relationships in psychiatry allow us to conclude that the demand of an ethical reflection in this specialty is even more imperative. Specific ethical considerations are made about some customary activities of psychiatrists such as diagnosing, pharmacological prescription and psychotherapy. 1.-
the facts that psychiatric diagnoses are based in conventions, are undemonstratable and that the patient's familial and work life depend on them, forces a careful management. 2.-Pharmacotherapy: due to the high proportion of secondary effects of pharmacological agents used in psychiatry -some of them irreversible- and the sort of human spirit manipulation that their use implicates, their indication must be painstaking. 3.- Psychotherapy: its legitimacy is the fundamental question, since the influence that a psychotherapist may get to have over his patients could be enormous. Aiming to find the real place of "healing by the word" in medicine, some Platonic texts are surveyed.
重新审视了医学中伦理问题重要性的历史原因。对精神病学中医患关系的分析使我们得出结论,该专业对伦理反思的需求更为迫切。针对精神科医生的一些常规活动,如诊断、药物处方和心理治疗,进行了具体的伦理考量。1. 诊断:精神科诊断基于惯例、无法证实且患者的家庭和工作生活依赖于此,这些事实迫使我们进行谨慎处理。2. 药物治疗:由于精神科使用的药物副作用比例很高——其中一些是不可逆的——且其使用涉及对人类精神的某种操控,因此用药指征必须谨慎。3. 心理治疗:其合理性是根本问题,因为心理治疗师对患者可能产生的影响可能非常巨大。为了探寻“言语治疗”在医学中的真正地位,对一些柏拉图式的文本进行了研究。