Malfi B, Picciotto G, Manzione A, Turello E, Squiccimarro G, Messina M, Segoloni G P
Divisione di Nefrologia e Dialisi, Ospedale S, Giovanni Battista, Molinette, Torino.
Minerva Urol Nefrol. 1993 Mar;45(1):1-4.
The diagnostic tools used to achieve an assessment of allograft dysfunction should be as noninvasive as possible, because kidney graft recipients are fragile patients and quite often the need is for repeated investigations. In order to evaluate the reliability and accuracy of such a method, in this case scintigraphy with 99mTc-DTPA, the authors retrospectively studied 2 groups of kidney transplanted patients, having two different basic immunosuppressive regimens: group A--86 patients--taking steroids and azathioprine; group B--93 patients--taking steroids and cyclosporine. A total of 722 scans were retrospectively compared with scintigraphic information: 196 episodes of allograft dysfunction were due to acute rejection: 118 in group A, 78 in group B; 117 episodes were due to ATN: 75 in group A, 42 in group B; 11 episodes were ascribed to CyA acute nephrotoxicity. Group A and B behave differently in respect of the perfusion index. Only in group A were perfusion indexes statistically different in rejection, ATN and nephrotoxicity. Anyway, it must be stressed that, even if in group B, scintigraphy cannot be considered an accurate diagnostic method, it is somehow a helpful tool because it gives information about a worse perfusion of the graft, independently of the underlying pathology.
用于评估同种异体移植肾功能障碍的诊断工具应尽可能无创,因为肾移植受者是脆弱的患者,而且常常需要反复进行检查。为了评估一种方法(在本案例中为99mTc-DTPA闪烁扫描)的可靠性和准确性,作者回顾性研究了两组接受肾移植的患者,他们采用两种不同的基本免疫抑制方案:A组——86例患者——服用类固醇和硫唑嘌呤;B组——93例患者——服用类固醇和环孢素。共对722次扫描结果与闪烁扫描信息进行了回顾性比较:196次同种异体移植肾功能障碍发作是由急性排斥反应引起的:A组118次,B组78次;117次发作是由急性肾小管坏死(ATN)引起的:A组75次,B组42次;11次发作归因于环孢素急性肾毒性。A组和B组在灌注指数方面表现不同。仅在A组中,排斥反应、急性肾小管坏死和肾毒性时的灌注指数存在统计学差异。无论如何,必须强调的是,即使在B组中,闪烁扫描不能被视为一种准确的诊断方法,但它在某种程度上仍是一种有用的工具,因为它能提供有关移植肾灌注较差的信息,而与潜在的病理情况无关。