Perko M J, Just S
Department of Vascular Surgery, Rigshospitalet, Copenhagen, Denmark.
J Ultrasound Med. 1993 May;12(5):259-63. doi: 10.7863/jum.1993.12.5.259.
The aim of this study was to evaluate the interobserver variability during duplex ultrasonographic investigation of the SMA. Eleven healthy volunteers were examined twice under the same conditions by two independent observers. Three basic Doppler wave parameters were assessed for the SMA: pV, edV, and rT. The tD was recorded for SMA and abdominal aorta (AotD) with B-mode imaging. The interobserver variability was very low for all parameters: pV = 13.5 cm/s; edV = 3.4 cm/s; rT = 0.01 s; tD = 0.3 mm; AotD = 0.5 mm, with corresponding 95% confidence intervals as follows: pV = 19 cm/s; edV = 4.7 cm/s; rT = 0.015 s; tD = 0.4 mm; and AotD = 0.75 mm. Coefficients of variation also showed very low dispersion for results obtained. Under the appropriate standard conditions for duplex sonographic examination of the mesenteric artery, assessments of basic Doppler wave parameters do not differ significantly between independent investigators. Reliable evaluation of B-mode distances can be obtained by replication of measurements.
本研究的目的是评估在肠系膜上动脉(SMA)的双功超声检查过程中观察者间的变异性。11名健康志愿者在相同条件下由两名独立观察者进行了两次检查。对SMA评估了三个基本多普勒波参数:峰值流速(pV)、舒张末期流速(edV)和阻力指数(rT)。通过B型成像记录了SMA和腹主动脉的管径(tD和腹主动脉管径[AotD])。所有参数的观察者间变异性都非常低:pV = 13.5 cm/s;edV = 3.4 cm/s;rT = 0.01 s;tD = 0.3 mm;AotD = 0.5 mm,相应的95%置信区间如下:pV = 19 cm/s;edV = 4.7 cm/s;rT = 0.015 s;tD = 0.4 mm;AotD = 0.75 mm。变异系数也显示所获得结果的离散度非常低。在肠系膜动脉双功超声检查的适当标准条件下,独立研究者对基本多普勒波参数的评估没有显著差异。通过重复测量可以获得对B型图像距离的可靠评估。