Heininger U, Cherry J D, Eckhardt T, Lorenz C, Christenson P, Stehr K
Universitätsklinik für Kinder und Jugendliche, Erlangen, Germany.
Pediatr Infect Dis J. 1993 Jun;12(6):504-9. doi: 10.1097/00006454-199306000-00009.
As a support service for a pertussis vaccine efficacy trial, a central diagnostic laboratory was established. Physicians in the geographic areas of the planned study were encouraged to send nasopharyngeal specimens from children and household contacts with cough illnesses whether or not the illnesses were typical of pertussis. From April, 1991, to February, 1992, 3629 specimens were received and in 601 instances (16.6%) Bordetella pertussis was isolated. Only 3.3% of patients with positive cultures had received pertussis vaccine whereas 16.1% of culture-negative patients had received vaccine (P < 0.0001). Fever was more common (12.2%) in patients with negative cultures compared with those with positive cultures (5.4%) (P < 0.0001). B. pertussis isolation rates fell markedly after 21 days of cough. Significantly more patients with negative cultures compared with those with positive cultures had been treated with erythromycin (8.5 vs. 2.9%; P < 0.0001). Patients with cough for greater than 4 weeks and specimen collection within 2 weeks of cough onset had a B. pertussis isolation rate of 59%. Similarly if whoop occurred under the same circumstances the isolation rate was 80%. In this study 25.5% of patients with culture confirmed pertussis had illnesses with cough of less than 21 days duration. This finding suggests to us that a pertussis case definition in efficacy trials that requires cough of 21 days is excessively restrictive.
作为一项百日咳疫苗效力试验的支持性服务,设立了一个中央诊断实验室。鼓励计划开展研究地区的医生,将咳嗽患儿及家庭接触者的鼻咽标本送来,无论这些疾病是否具有百日咳的典型症状。从1991年4月至1992年2月,共收到3629份标本,其中601份(16.6%)分离出百日咳博德特氏菌。培养阳性的患者中只有3.3%接种过百日咳疫苗,而培养阴性的患者中有16.1%接种过疫苗(P<0.0001)。培养阴性的患者发热更为常见(12.2%),而培养阳性的患者中发热的比例为5.4%(P<0.0001)。咳嗽21天后,百日咳博德特氏菌的分离率显著下降。与培养阳性的患者相比,培养阴性的患者接受红霉素治疗的比例明显更高(8.5%对2.9%;P<0.0001)。咳嗽超过4周且在咳嗽发作后2周内采集标本的患者,百日咳博德特氏菌的分离率为59%。同样,在相同情况下出现哮吼声的患者,分离率为80%。在本研究中,培养确诊为百日咳的患者中有25.5%咳嗽病程少于21天。这一发现提示我们,效力试验中要求咳嗽21天的百日咳病例定义限制过严。