Avioli L V
Division of Bone and Mineral Diseases, Washington University, St. Louis, Missouri.
Ann Ital Med Int. 1993 Apr-Jun;8(2):121-8.
The authors examine the effects of different drugs used in osteoporosis therapy for the primary and secondary prevention of fractures. They base their review on prospective randomized studies; retrospective studies are included only if a consistent number of subjects has been examined. Their methodological characteristics are illustrated, and results with significant levels and 95% confidence intervals are reported. Only hormone replacement therapy and salmon calcitonin have been demonstrated as able to prevent vertebral and non-vertebral fractures. Vitamin D and its analogues seem to be effective only in elderly patients, although conclusive data are lacking. With regard to bisphosphonates, only data on vertebral fractures are presently available. Results from fluoride studies are still very inconclusive, and, in fact, lead to the hypothesis of a fracture-promoting effect. At present, no data on ipriflavone are available. Considerably more research is necessary to define the efficacy of different treatment protocols for fracture prevention. Each therapeutic proposal for osteoporosis should be supported by data on its efficacy in reducing the incidence of fractures. Not always, in fact, is an absolute increase of bone mass followed by the effective prevention of fractures. At this time, only estrogens and calcitonin have been demonstrated as able to reduce fracture incidence.
作者们研究了用于骨质疏松症治疗以预防原发性和继发性骨折的不同药物的效果。他们的综述基于前瞻性随机研究;仅当检查了一致数量的受试者时才纳入回顾性研究。阐述了这些研究的方法学特征,并报告了具有显著水平和95%置信区间的结果。只有激素替代疗法和鲑鱼降钙素已被证明能够预防椎体和非椎体骨折。维生素D及其类似物似乎仅在老年患者中有效,尽管缺乏确凿数据。关于双膦酸盐,目前仅有关于椎体骨折的数据。氟化物研究的结果仍然非常不确定,实际上,这导致了其具有促进骨折作用的假说。目前,关于依普黄酮尚无数据。需要进行更多的研究来确定不同治疗方案预防骨折的疗效。骨质疏松症的每一项治疗建议都应以其降低骨折发生率的疗效数据为依据。事实上,并非总是骨量的绝对增加随后就能有效预防骨折。目前,只有雌激素和降钙素已被证明能够降低骨折发生率。