Buntinx F, Winkens R, Grol R, Knottnerus J A
Department of General Practice, Universities of Limburg, Maastricht, The Netherlands.
Fam Pract. 1993 Jun;10(2):219-28. doi: 10.1093/fampra/10.2.219.
The number of good quality studies on the effect of feedback and reminders on diagnostic and preventive activities in ambulant practice is still low. The interventions and procedures studied differ widely, and the reporting of the results is insufficiently precise. This makes comparison difficult and quantitative pooling impossible. Nevertheless, the literature supports the contention that feedback reduces the use of diagnostic tests and the costs thereby engendered. It also discloses a positive effect of feedback on the adherence of medical practice to guidelines or standards. In this respect, the effect of reminders seems to exceed that of classical methods of feedback. There is still a need for research on the effect of feedback, reminders and other instruments for quality assurance on various aspects of medical performance in different settings.
关于反馈和提醒对门诊实践中诊断及预防活动影响的高质量研究数量仍然较少。所研究的干预措施和程序差异很大,结果报告也不够精确。这使得比较困难且无法进行定量汇总。尽管如此,文献支持这样的观点,即反馈会减少诊断测试的使用及由此产生的成本。它还揭示了反馈对医疗实践遵循指南或标准的积极影响。在这方面,提醒的效果似乎超过了传统的反馈方法。仍有必要研究反馈、提醒及其他质量保证手段对不同环境下医疗绩效各个方面的影响。