Robert M, Bennani A, Chevallier P, Guiter J, Averous M, Grasset D
Service d'Urologie, Hôpital Lapeyronie, Montpellier.
Prog Urol. 1993 Jun;3(3):438-43.
25 hydroelectric endoureteric lithotripsies (Group 1, Riwolith) and 35 ballistic endoureteric lithotripsies (Group 2, Lithoclast) were analysed. 60 stones were treated, including 18 pelvic stones (Group 1 : 10, Group 2 : 8), 39 iliolumbar stones (Group 1 : 14, Group 2 : 25), and 3 stones of the ureteropelvic junction (Group 1 : 1, Group 2 : 2). The mean maximal diameter was 9.9 mm (Group 1 : 8.2, Group 2 : 11). Complementary Dormia extraction was performed in 24 cases (Group 1 : 8, Group 2 : 16), 55 double J stents were implanted (Group 1 : 24, Group 2 : 31) and 23 immediate ECL sessions were performed (Group 1 : 8, Group 2 : 15). Overall, 57 good results were recorded, but 3 complete failures of fragmentation and 2 severe ureteric lesions were attributed to hydroelectric lithotripsy. The Lithoclast, much less traumatic, had a greater stone fragmentation potential, but its efficacy on very mobile stones is limited due to its more intense stone propulsion effect.
对25例水电式输尿管内碎石术(第1组,Riwolith)和35例弹道式输尿管内碎石术(第2组,Lithoclast)进行了分析。共治疗60块结石,其中包括18块肾盂结石(第1组:10块,第2组:8块)、39块髂腰段结石(第1组:14块,第2组:25块)以及3块输尿管肾盂连接处结石(第1组:1块,第2组:2块)。平均最大直径为9.9毫米(第1组:8.2毫米,第2组:11毫米)。24例患者进行了辅助Dormia取石术(第1组:8例,第2组:16例),植入了55根双J支架(第1组:24根,第2组:31根),并进行了23次即时体外冲击波碎石术(ECL)治疗(第1组:8次,第2组:15次)。总体而言,记录到57例良好结果,但有3例碎石完全失败,2例严重输尿管损伤归因于水电式碎石术。Lithoclast创伤性小得多,具有更大的碎石潜力,但其对极活动结石的疗效因较强的结石推进作用而受限。