Hunter T B, Marcus D S, Witzke D B
Department of Radiology, University of Arizona, Tucson 85724.
Invest Radiol. 1993 Aug;28(8):706-9. doi: 10.1097/00004424-199308000-00011.
We assessed radiologists' perceptions of radiologic and general medical journals.
Five thousand randomly chosen radiologists (4,200 American College of Radiology (ACR) members and 800 members in training) were surveyed by mail concerning their opinion of selected radiology and major medical journals. The mail survey was followed up by a phone survey of 45 previously unsurveyed radiologists from a smaller list of a similar ACR population.
Of the 5,000 surveys mailed out, 987 (20%) were completed and returned. There were no systematic differences in the questionnaire results between those surveyed by phone and those surveyed by mail. In general, academic radiologists, private practice radiologists, and radiologists in training did not differ in their assessment of professional journals. The respondents picked Radiology as their first choice if they were allowed to read only one journal. The respondents believed that Radiology published the best clinical research and Investigative Radiology the best basic science research. American Journal of Roentgenology (AJR), Radiology, and Journal of Computer Assisted Tomography ranked highest for sureness and rapidity of manuscript acceptance and publication, while Radiology, New England Journal of Medicine, and the Journal of the American Medical Association ranked highest in terms of exposure and prestige.
我们评估了放射科医生对放射学和普通医学期刊的看法。
通过邮件对5000名随机挑选的放射科医生（4200名美国放射学会（ACR）成员和800名正在接受培训的成员）进行了调查，询问他们对选定的放射学和主要医学期刊的看法。在邮件调查之后，对来自ACR类似人群的较小名单中的45名之前未接受调查的放射科医生进行了电话调查。
在寄出的5000份调查问卷中，987份（20%）被填写并返回。电话调查对象和邮件调查对象的问卷结果没有系统性差异。总体而言，学术放射科医生、私人执业放射科医生和正在接受培训的放射科医生在对专业期刊的评估上没有差异。如果只允许阅读一本期刊，受访者将《放射学》选为首选。受访者认为《放射学》发表了最好的临床研究，《介入放射学》发表了最好的基础科学研究。《美国放射学杂志》（AJR）、《放射学》和《计算机断层扫描杂志》在稿件接受和发表的确定性和速度方面排名最高，而《放射学》、《新英格兰医学杂志》和《美国医学会杂志》在曝光度和声望方面排名最高。
