Schraube P, Fritz P, Becker H D, Wannenmacher M
Radiologische Klinik, Universität Heidelberg.
Strahlenther Onkol. 1993 Apr;169(4):228-34.
Between November 1987 and July 1991 34 patients with a non-small-cell lung cancer were treated with an endobronchial iridium-192 high-dose-rate afterloading therapy. In 13 patients with relapses after percutaneous irradiation brachytherapy was the sole radiotherapy modality with 20 (5 to 29) Gy within 14 (one to 42) days in four (one to six) fractions in a palliative sense. Endoscopically controlled, seven remissions (four complete, three partial) could be achieved. The median duration to local progression was two months, the median survival of this group was nine months. In 21 patients with a medically or surgically unresectable tumor a combined percutaneous (51 [46 to 60] Gy within 4.5 to six weeks) and endobronchial irradiation was done. This patient group consisted of one stage IV, eight stage IIIb, 8 stage IIIa, 1 stage II, 1 stage I patients and two patients with tumor relapses after surgery. Patients were selected for combined therapy by a mostly endo/peribronchial tumor volume. The brachytherapy was applied after an interval of 16 (one to 48) days with 17.5 (9 to 20) Gy in three to four fractions. In 13 patients six to eight weeks after treatment a complete remission by endoscopy was found. Patients with a complete remission had a statistically better survival than the remaining patients. The median estimated survival of this group until local progression was 16 months, the median survival 20 months. In all patients there were two occurrences of hemorrhage (one group I, one group II) and one tracheo-mediastinal fistula (group II), but in no case of these fatal events a local tumor control had been reached. In three patients radiogenic bronchitis occurred up to a degree, which demanded endoscopic interventions. This study suggests, that there might be a subgroup of centrally located lung cancer with endo/peribronchial tumor mass, which gains by a combined radiation treatment with an acceptable risk of side effects. The results should be evaluated in further randomized studies.
1987年11月至1991年7月期间,34例非小细胞肺癌患者接受了支气管内铱-192高剂量率后装治疗。13例经皮照射后复发的患者,姑息性短距离放射疗法是唯一的放射治疗方式,在14天(1至42天)内分4次(1至6次)给予20(5至29)Gy。在内镜控制下,可实现7例缓解(4例完全缓解,3例部分缓解)。局部进展的中位持续时间为2个月,该组的中位生存期为9个月。21例医学上或手术上无法切除肿瘤的患者接受了经皮(4.5至6周内51 [46至60] Gy)和支气管内照射联合治疗。该患者组包括1例IV期、8例IIIb期、8例IIIa期、1例II期、1例I期患者以及2例术后肿瘤复发患者。联合治疗的患者主要根据支气管内/支气管周围肿瘤体积进行选择。短距离放射疗法在间隔16天(1至48天)后进行,分3至4次给予17.5(9至20)Gy。13例患者在治疗后6至8周经内镜检查发现完全缓解。完全缓解的患者生存期在统计学上优于其余患者。该组直至局部进展的中位估计生存期为16个月,中位生存期为20个月。所有患者中发生了2例出血(1例I组,1例II组)和1例气管纵隔瘘(II组),但这些致命事件均未达到局部肿瘤控制。3例患者发生了放射性支气管炎,严重程度需进行内镜干预。本研究表明,可能存在一组以支气管内/支气管周围肿瘤块为特征的中央型肺癌患者,联合放射治疗可使其受益,且副作用风险可接受。结果应在进一步的随机研究中进行评估。