Bartsiokas A, Day M H
Department of Human Anatomy and Cell Biology, University of Liverpool, U.K.
Proc Biol Sci. 1993 May 22;252(1334):115-23. doi: 10.1098/rspb.1993.0054.
Doubts about the attribution of the Trinil femur to Homo erectus on anatomical grounds have a long history. Here, for the first time, published stratigraphic information and chemical evidence based on the Ca/P ratios confirm that the anatomical doubts are justified. The Trinil femur apparently belongs to a more recent stratum above the 'fossil layer' (Hauptknochenschicht, HK) in which the Trinil calotte was found. It is concluded that the Trinil Femur I belongs to Homo sapiens, whereas the Trinil Femora II-V and the calotte belong to H. erectus. The chemical evidence derives from the use of electron probe energy dispersive X-ray microanalysis (EDXA), a technique that can be virtually non-destructive and therefore may be used on scarce fossil evidence.
基于解剖学依据对直立人特里尼尔股骨归属的质疑由来已久。在此,首次发表的地层信息以及基于钙磷比的化学证据证实了这些解剖学上的质疑是合理的。特里尼尔股骨显然属于发现特里尼尔头盖骨的“化石层”(主骨层,HK)之上的一个更新的地层。得出的结论是,特里尼尔股骨I属于智人,而特里尼尔股骨II - V以及头盖骨属于直立人。化学证据源自电子探针能量色散X射线微分析(EDXA)技术的应用,该技术几乎不会造成破坏,因此可用于稀缺的化石证据。