Bacon P J, Smith S E
Department of Clinical Pharmacology, United Medical School, Guy's Hospital, London, UK.
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1993 Oct;56(10):1096-102. doi: 10.1136/jnnp.56.10.1096.
A cross-sectional study is reported in which 53 patients with Holmes-Adie syndrome have been subjected to a battery of tests of autonomic nervous function referable to the cardiovascular system, to two objective tests of sweating function, and to subjective assessment of sweating by application of quinizarin powder followed by body heating. The majority of patients were consecutive referrals; none was selected because of clinical indications of autonomic dysfunction. Eighty three per cent of these patients had at least one, 57% at least two, and 40% at least three objective test abnormalities, as defined by values lying outside 95 percentiles of healthy subjects who were matched for age and subjected to the same tests. In the context of multiple testing, the probability of finding outside values was such that a minimum of 3 was required to define abnormality. On this basis 40% of patients were found to have significant evidence of autonomic dysfunction. The most frequent abnormalities were impaired digital vasoconstriction to cold (23%), a reduced heart rate response to the Valsalva manoeuvre (17%), and excessive variability in sweating between test sites (in one of the tests, 43%) which is consistent with patchy loss. Abnormal quinizarin test appearances were seen in 10 patients and in a further five patients the appearances were thought to be suggestive of abnormality. Though assessment of the results of this test are subjective, the observations are consistent with the findings obtained from the objective tests which were applied. Cardiovascular and sweating abnormality did not concur significantly and only the former was found to increase progressively with known duration of the pupillotonia. It is concluded that Holmes-Adie syndrome is commonly accompanied by progressive mild but widespread autonomic involvement but rarely is this symptomatic. If symptoms suggestive of autonomic neuropathy are found in a patient with tonic pupils, a careful search for some other generalised disorder is recommended.
本文报告了一项横断面研究,研究对象为53例霍姆斯-阿迪综合征患者,他们接受了一系列与心血管系统相关的自主神经功能测试、两项出汗功能客观测试,以及通过涂抹醌茜素粉末并随后加热身体来进行出汗主观评估。大多数患者是连续转诊而来;没有因自主神经功能障碍的临床指征而被挑选。这些患者中,83%至少有一项、57%至少有两项、40%至少有三项客观测试异常,异常定义为超出年龄匹配且接受相同测试的健康受试者95%百分位数的值。在多次测试的情况下,发现超出正常范围值的概率使得至少需要3项异常才能定义为异常。在此基础上,发现40%的患者有自主神经功能障碍的显著证据。最常见的异常是对寒冷的手指血管收缩受损(23%)、对瓦尔萨尔瓦动作的心率反应降低(17%),以及测试部位之间出汗的过度变异性(在其中一项测试中为43%),这与局部丧失一致。10例患者出现异常的醌茜素测试表现,另有5例患者的表现被认为提示异常。尽管该测试结果的评估是主观的,但观察结果与应用的客观测试结果一致。心血管和出汗异常没有显著同时出现,仅发现前者随已知瞳孔强直持续时间逐渐增加。结论是,霍姆斯-阿迪综合征通常伴有渐进性轻度但广泛的自主神经受累,但很少有症状。如果在瞳孔强直的患者中发现提示自主神经病变的症状,建议仔细寻找其他全身性疾病。