Sisti M B, Kader A, Stein B M
Neurological Institute, Columbia-Presbyterian Medical Center, New York, New York.
J Neurosurg. 1993 Nov;79(5):653-60. doi: 10.3171/jns.1993.79.5.0653.
The surgical outcome in a series of small arteriovenous malformations (AVM's) that might have been considered optimal for radiosurgery is reviewed. In a total microsurgical series of 360 patients, 67 (19%) underwent resection of AVM's less than 3 cm in largest diameter, regardless of location. Many of these lesions (45%) were in locations that might be considered surgically inaccessible such as the thalamus, brain stem, medial hemisphere, and paraventricular regions. Complete angiographic obliteration of the AVM by microsurgical technique was accomplished in 63 patients (94%) with a surgical morbidity of 1.5% and no operative mortality. Patients with hemispheric AVM's had a cure rate of 100% and no neurological morbidity. Stereotactically guided craniotomy was used in 14 patients (21%) to locate and resect deep or concealed malformations. The results from five major radiosurgery centers treating similar-sized AVM's are analyzed. The authors' surgical results compare favorably with those from radiosurgery centers which, in their opinion, supports the conclusion that microneurosurgery is superior to radiosurgery, except for a small percentage of lesions that are truly inoperable on the basis of inaccessibility.
回顾了一系列可能被认为是放射外科最佳适应证的小型动静脉畸形(AVM)的手术结果。在总共360例显微手术患者中,67例(19%)接受了最大直径小于3 cm的AVM切除术,无论其位置如何。这些病变中有许多(45%)位于手术难以到达的部位,如丘脑、脑干、大脑半球内侧和脑室旁区域。63例患者(94%)通过显微外科技术实现了AVM的完全血管造影闭塞,手术并发症发生率为1.5%,无手术死亡。半球型AVM患者的治愈率为100%,无神经功能并发症。14例患者(21%)采用立体定向引导开颅术定位并切除深部或隐匿性畸形。分析了五个主要放射外科中心治疗类似大小AVM的结果。作者的手术结果与放射外科中心的结果相比具有优势,他们认为这支持了以下结论:除了一小部分因难以到达而真正无法手术的病变外,显微神经外科手术优于放射外科手术。