Mingoli A, Sciacca V, Tamorri M, Fiume D, Sapienza P
1st Department of Surgery, La Sapienza University, Rome.
Angiology. 1993 Jan;44(1):21-5. doi: 10.1177/000331979304400104.
Between 1982 and 1990, 76 patients (33 women, 43 men, mean age 71.4 +/- 10 years) affected with limb-threatening peripheral vascular disease (claudication < 20 m: 3 patients; rest pain: 10 patients; necrosis1 smaller than 3 cm2: 28 patients; necrosis2 larger than 3 cm2: 35 patients) not amenable to medical and/or surgical therapy, were treated by epidural spinal cord electrical stimulation (ESES). Effectiveness of ESES was evaluated by consideration of pain control, walking distance, and healing of ischemic lesions. At a mean follow-up of twenty-six months (range: one to seventy-six) 44 limbs (58%) were amputated (rest pain 2; necrosis1 13; necrosis2 29) and 39% of necrotic lesions smaller than 3 cm2 healed. The overall limb salvage rate was 42%. Pain control was obtained in 80% of patients at the one-year and 75% at the two-year follow-up, with infrequent use of pain relievers. Despite the poor clinical results observed, the limb salvage rate testifies to the effectiveness of ESES in limb-threatening ischemia. Moreover, the authors noticed a good ESES effect on pain relief, maximal in the early and intermediate postimplant periods. In conclusion ESES must be considered the last resort in peripheral vascular disease in patients in whom medical and/or surgical therapies are ineffective or impossible. Necrotic lesions larger than 3 cm2 contraindicate, in their opinion, ESES implant.
1982年至1990年间,76例患有威胁肢体的周围血管疾病(跛行距离<20米:3例;静息痛:10例;坏死面积小于3平方厘米:28例;坏死面积大于3平方厘米:35例)且不适合药物和/或手术治疗的患者(33名女性,43名男性,平均年龄71.4±10岁)接受了硬膜外脊髓电刺激(ESES)治疗。通过考虑疼痛控制、步行距离和缺血性病变的愈合情况来评估ESES的有效性。平均随访26个月(范围:1至76个月)后,44条肢体(58%)被截肢(静息痛2例;坏死面积小于3平方厘米13例;坏死面积大于3平方厘米29例),39%的坏死面积小于3平方厘米的病变愈合。总体肢体挽救率为42%。在一年随访时,80%的患者疼痛得到控制,两年随访时为75%,且很少使用止痛药物。尽管观察到临床效果不佳,但肢体挽救率证明了ESES在威胁肢体的缺血性疾病中的有效性。此外,作者注意到ESES对疼痛缓解有良好效果,在植入后的早期和中期效果最佳。总之,对于药物和/或手术治疗无效或无法进行的周围血管疾病患者,ESES必须被视为最后的治疗手段。他们认为,坏死面积大于3平方厘米的病变禁忌植入ESES。