Hall P, Brockington I F, Levings J, Murphy C
Woodbourne Clinic, Birmingham.
Br J Psychiatry. 1993 Jan;162:99-108. doi: 10.1192/bjp.162.1.99.
Vignettes representing mentally ill people were presented to about 2000 randomly selected residents in Bromsgrove, served by a mental hospital, and Malvern, served by a community-based psychiatric service. They were asked about the likely cause of the condition, what action they would take, and what agencies were most likely to help. In Malvern, residents seemed more enterprising in involving various agencies and more tolerant. It is possible to derive simple 'action scores' as an indicator of such tolerance. Although there were significant demographic differences between subgroups, overall identification of vignette subjects as mentally ill was surprisingly low, and so was knowledge both of community psychiatric nurses as an agency, and of the location of dispersed treatment facilities in both areas.
向约2000名随机挑选的居民展示了代表精神疾病患者的短文。这些居民来自布罗姆斯格罗夫(由一家精神病院提供服务)和马尔文(由社区精神科服务机构提供服务)。研究人员询问他们关于病情可能的病因、他们会采取什么行动以及最有可能提供帮助的机构。在马尔文,居民在联系各种机构方面似乎更积极主动,也更宽容。可以得出简单的“行动得分”作为这种宽容度的一个指标。尽管不同亚组之间存在显著的人口统计学差异,但总体而言,将短文中的对象识别为精神疾病患者的比例出奇地低,对社区精神科护士这一机构以及两个地区分散治疗设施位置的了解程度也很低。