Swensen S J, Gray J E, Brown L R, Aughenbaugh G L, Harms G F, Stears J
Department of Diagnostic Radiology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN 55905.
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1993 Mar;160(3):483-6. doi: 10.2214/ajr.160.3.8430540.
A new asymmetric screen-film combination for conventional chest radiography was evaluated by four thoracic radiologists.
Fifty chest radiographs obtained with a new asymmetric screen-film combination were compared with radiographs obtained in the same patients during the same breath-hold with a conventional system. Patients referred from the oncology service were studied because of the increased prevalence of abnormal findings on chest radiographs in this population. The differences in the quality of the images were assessed by four chest radiologists who used a direct-comparison technique. Eleven anatomic shadows that are normal on chest radiographs were assessed. Fifty abnormal findings also were compared.
The image quality of the new asymmetric screen-film combination was judged to be superior to that of the conventional system for normal anatomy and abnormal findings (p < or = .003).
The new asymmetric film consistently showed more clinically useful detail in the mediastinum and in the lung projected over the diaphragm and heart. The radiation dose was about 30% less with the new screen-film system.
四位胸部放射科医生对一种用于传统胸部X线摄影的新型非对称增感屏-胶片组合进行了评估。
将使用新型非对称增感屏-胶片组合获得的50例胸部X线片与同一患者在相同屏气状态下使用传统系统获得的X线片进行比较。研究了肿瘤科室转诊的患者,因为该人群胸部X线片异常发现的患病率较高。四位胸部放射科医生采用直接比较技术评估图像质量。评估了胸部X线片上11个正常的解剖阴影。还比较了50个异常发现。
对于正常解剖结构和异常发现,新型非对称增感屏-胶片组合的图像质量被判定优于传统系统(p≤0.003)。
新型非对称胶片在纵隔以及投射在膈肌和心脏上方的肺部始终显示出更多对临床有用的细节。新型增感屏-胶片系统的辐射剂量减少了约30%。