Nomura Y, Tominaga T, Abe O, Izuo M, Ogawa N
Dept. of Breast Surgery, National Kyushu Cancer Center, Fukuoka, Japan.
Gan To Kagaku Ryoho. 1993 Feb;20(2):247-58.
Efficacy and safety of NK 622 (toremifene citrate) were compared with tamoxifen (TAM) by a double blind test in patients with advanced or recurrent breast cancer. NK 622 and TAM were given orally for 12 weeks or more at daily doses of 40 and 20 mg/body, respectively. Eligible cases in NK622 and TAM groups were both 57 patients. No significant difference was observed in patient characteristics between either group. Response rates were 26.3% (8 CR and 7 PR, 15/57) in the NK 622 group and 28.1% (3 CR and 13 PR, 16/57) in the TAM group. Median values of duration to onset of CR were 91 days in the NK 622 group and 169 days in the TAM group. The duration was significantly shorter with the NK 622 group. Median duration of efficacy in CR and PR cases was 155 days in the NK 622 group and 154.5 days in the TAM group. Adverse effects were encountered in 7 patients (12.3%) of each of the 2 groups. The side effects were fatigue, hot flush, WBC decrease, abnormal values in liver function tests, etc. in the NK 622 group and anorexia, nausea, eruption, feeling of warmth, sweating, dry mouth, dizziness, abnormal values in liver function tests, etc. in the TAM group. Administration was discontinued in one patient with eruption and another patient with abnormal values of liver function tests in the TAM group, while there was no such case in the NK 622 group. Including the discontinued cases, the side effects were moderate and reversible in both groups. The patients in whom a drug was determined as useful or more numbered 24/57 (42.1%) in the NK 622 group and 23/57 (40.4%) in the TAM group. There was not significant difference between the 2 groups in the above results except the duration to onset of CR. From these results, NK 622 is expected to show comparable efficacy, safety, and usefulness in patients undergoing TAM treatment for advanced or recurrent breast cancer.
通过双盲试验,在晚期或复发性乳腺癌患者中比较了NK 622(枸橼酸托瑞米芬)与他莫昔芬(TAM)的疗效和安全性。NK 622和TAM分别以40和20mg/体的日剂量口服给药12周或更长时间。NK622组和TAM组的合格病例均为57例患者。两组患者的特征无显著差异。NK 622组的缓解率为26.3%(8例完全缓解和7例部分缓解,15/57),TAM组为28.1%(3例完全缓解和13例部分缓解,16/57)。NK 622组完全缓解开始时间的中位数为91天,TAM组为169天。NK 622组的持续时间明显更短。NK 622组完全缓解和部分缓解病例的疗效中位数持续时间为155天,TAM组为154.5天。两组各有7例患者(12.3%)出现不良反应。NK 622组的副作用为疲劳、潮热、白细胞减少、肝功能检查值异常等,TAM组为厌食、恶心、皮疹、发热感、出汗、口干、头晕、肝功能检查值异常等。TAM组有1例皮疹患者和另1例肝功能检查值异常患者停药,而NK 622组无此情况。包括停药病例在内,两组的副作用均为中度且可逆。NK 622组中被判定为有效或更有效的患者有24/57(42.1%),TAM组为23/57(40.4%)。除完全缓解开始时间外,两组上述结果无显著差异。从这些结果来看,预计NK 622在接受TAM治疗的晚期或复发性乳腺癌患者中具有相当的疗效、安全性和实用性。