Taylor N E, Rosenthal R N, Chabus B, Levine S, Hoffman A S, Reynolds J, Santos L, Willets I, Friedman P
Department of Psychiatry, Beth Israel Medical Center, New York, NY 10003.
Gen Hosp Psychiatry. 1993 Jan;15(1):36-40. doi: 10.1016/0163-8343(93)90089-7.
We conducted a prospective study of a smoking ban on a general inpatient psychiatry service in response to staff concerns about the feasibility of a proposed hospital-wide ban. Demographic information, smoking history, and DSM III-R diagnoses were obtained for consecutively admitted patients during two study conditions: smoking and nonsmoking. A log of p.r.n. medication, seclusion, restraint, elopement, incident reports, and smoking-related discharges was kept for each patient. Chi-square analysis of 232 patients for whom demographic, smoking, diagnostic, and log data were complete showed no significant differences between study conditions for demographic or diagnostic variables. Two-tailed t-test analysis of the log data for these 232 patients showed no significant difference in disruptive incidents during smoking and nonsmoking conditions (p = 0.183). Fifty staff members answered pre- and post-ban questionnaires. Paired t-test analysis demonstrated a significant change in staff attitude toward supporting the ban. These data indicate that smoking can be stopped on inpatient psychiatry units without increases in unit disruption or adverse effects on staff morale.
针对工作人员对拟议的全院禁烟可行性的担忧,我们对综合住院精神科服务的禁烟情况进行了一项前瞻性研究。在吸烟和不吸烟这两种研究条件下,收集了连续入院患者的人口统计学信息、吸烟史和DSM III-R诊断结果。为每位患者记录了按需用药、隔离、约束、逃跑、事件报告以及与吸烟相关的出院情况。对232例人口统计学、吸烟、诊断和日志数据完整的患者进行卡方分析,结果显示在研究条件之间,人口统计学或诊断变量没有显著差异。对这232例患者的日志数据进行双尾t检验分析,结果显示在吸烟和不吸烟条件下,干扰事件没有显著差异(p = 0.183)。50名工作人员回答了禁烟前和禁烟后的问卷。配对t检验分析表明,工作人员对支持禁烟的态度发生了显著变化。这些数据表明,在住院精神科病房可以停止吸烟,而不会增加病房的干扰或对工作人员士气产生不利影响。