Palma L, Celli P, Cantore G
Neurosurgical Clinic, Siena University Medical School, Italy.
Neurosurgery. 1993 Feb;32(2):169-75. doi: 10.1227/00006123-199302000-00003.
In order to better elucidate the lesser known aspects of the biological behavior and prognosis of supratentorial ependymomas in children and young adults, we studied a series of 20 patients, ages 1 to 20 years. The tumor site was extraventricular in 14 cases and intraventricular in 6 (including one third ventricle tumor). Histologically, according to World Health Organization criteria, there were 12 ependymomas (E), 2 subependymomas (SE), and 6 malignant ependymomas (ME). Of the 18 patients surviving surgery, 12 (66.6%) are alive and disease free 63 to 252 months (mean, 146 mo) after the operation; 9 harbored an E, 2 had an SE and 1 had an ME. Four patients are now out of risk of recurrence according to Collin's law. Six of the long-term survivors (50%), four E and two SE, did not receive postoperative radiotherapy. However, two patients with E, initially treated by surgery alone, had a recurrence and one subsequently died. Two ME patients showed signs of spinal metastases after subsequent operation for recurrence and shortly before death. Considering the partially good results as well as failures after surgery alone in our and in other series and the risks of irradiating the child's brain, we tried to elucidate in what cases radiotherapy could be reasonably withheld, or alternatively, when prophylactic craniospinal irradiation should be prescribed. The main conclusions of our study are the following: 1) Radical surgery alone is a reasonable option as the initial treatment for lateral ventricle tumors and for solid extraventricular tumors located far from eloquent brain areas, provided the histology is benign, especially if of the SE type.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
为了更好地阐明儿童和青年幕上室管膜瘤生物学行为和预后方面鲜为人知的情况,我们研究了一组20例年龄在1至20岁的患者。肿瘤位于脑室外的有14例,位于脑室内的有6例(包括1例第三脑室肿瘤)。组织学上,根据世界卫生组织标准,有12例室管膜瘤(E)、2例室管膜下瘤(SE)和6例恶性室管膜瘤(ME)。18例手术后存活的患者中,12例(66.6%)在术后63至252个月(平均146个月)仍存活且无疾病;其中9例为E,2例为SE,1例为ME。根据柯林法则,4例患者目前已无复发风险。6例长期存活者(50%),4例E和2例SE,未接受术后放疗。然而,2例最初仅接受手术治疗的E患者复发,其中1例随后死亡。2例ME患者在后续复发手术后及死亡前不久出现脊髓转移迹象。考虑到我们和其他系列中单纯手术后部分良好的结果以及失败情况,以及对儿童脑部进行放疗的风险,我们试图阐明在哪些情况下可以合理地不进行放疗,或者在哪些情况下应进行预防性全脑脊髓放疗。我们研究的主要结论如下:1)对于侧脑室肿瘤以及位于远离明确脑功能区的实性脑室外肿瘤,若组织学为良性,尤其是SE类型,单纯根治性手术作为初始治疗是合理的选择。