Yamakawa M
Department of Radiology and Radiation Oncology, Gunma University School of Medicine.
Nihon Igaku Hoshasen Gakkai Zasshi. 1993 Jan 25;53(1):91-100.
Tumor response to twice-a-day irradiation (BID) at smaller doses than 2 Gy on mammary carcinoma of C3H/He mouse (alpha/beta ratio = 18 Gy) was studied with comparison of once-a-day irradiation (QD) in the same overall treatment time. The dose per fraction (dBID) was ranged from 110R to 162R in BID, and the dose per fraction (dQD) was ranged from 200R to 300R in QD fractionation (1R = 0.91 cGy). The number of fraction was 10 or 15 in QD, and 20 or 30 in BID. The interval of fractions was 4 hours in BID. Tumor response was assessed by tumor growth delay. MFD effect ratio, i.e., growth delay time of BID/growth delay time of QD, was significantly smaller than the ratio estimated from FDF formula, (alpha/beta + dBID) x dBID x NBID/(alpha/beta + dQD) x dQD x NQD, with decreasing fraction size. In the case of dBID = 120R and dQD = 200R, estimated ratio was 1.16, but MFD effect ratio was 0.58, regardless of 20% increments of daily dose. To get same or more tumor response, it is necessary to prolong the overall treatment time of twice-a-day irradiation. If the overall treatment time is same, it is estimated that the fraction size of BID equivalent to the fractionation of daily 200R is presumably 135R to this mouse tumor.
研究了C3H/He小鼠乳腺癌(α/β比值 = 18 Gy)在每天两次照射(BID)且剂量小于2 Gy时的肿瘤反应,并与相同总治疗时间下的每天一次照射(QD)进行了比较。BID的每次分割剂量(dBID)范围为110R至162R,QD分割的每次分割剂量(dQD)范围为200R至300R(1R = 0.91 cGy)。QD的分割次数为10次或15次,BID为20次或30次。BID的分割间隔为4小时。通过肿瘤生长延迟评估肿瘤反应。MFD效应比,即BID的生长延迟时间/QD的生长延迟时间,随着分割剂量减小,显著小于根据FDF公式(α/β + dBID)×dBID×NBID/(α/β + dQD)×dQD×NQD估算的比值。在dBID = 120R和dQD = 200R的情况下,估算比值为1.16,但MFD效应比为0.58,无论每日剂量增加20%。为获得相同或更多的肿瘤反应,有必要延长每天两次照射的总治疗时间。如果总治疗时间相同,据估计,对于这种小鼠肿瘤,与每天200R分割等效的BID分割剂量大概为135R。