Anderson R P, Guyton S W, Paull D L, Tidwell S L
Department of Surgery, Virginia Mason Clinic, Seattle, WA 98101.
J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 1993 Mar;105(3):444-51; discussion 451-2.
Between March 15, 1990, and December 31, 1991, we admitted to the Virginia Mason Hospital for isolated coronary bypass operations 175 consecutive patients with chronic, stable angina pectoris who had prior coronary arteriography. One hundred patients were admitted on the same day as their operations, and 75 patients, deemed to be at higher risk, were admitted 1 day before the operation. Postoperative progress of all patients was monitored by means of a clinical pathway form with physiologic and activity measures plotted against postoperative days. We found no difference in age, sex, or total number of comorbidity factors. Diabetes and ejection fraction less than 0.50 were significantly more common in preoperatively admitted patients and were independently predictive of admitting group. Significant differences between surgeons in the proportion of same-day patients admitted could not be explained by differences in common risk factors. There was no significant difference in postoperative major or minor complications or number of clinical pathway deviations, but two deaths occurred in patients admitted preoperatively. Average total hospital stay was 1 1/2 days less for same-day patients, a highly significant difference. Total hospital charges averaged $19,000 for the series and were $286 more for preoperatively admitted patients, a difference that was not statistically significant. Patients admitted selectively for same-day coronary bypass are not at risk for an increased number of complications. Although their hospital stay is reduced, the reduction of their hospital charges is minimal. Preoperative admission of patients with comorbidity requiring medical management or with physical incapacity remains justified, and admitting decisions should remain with the operating surgeon, not third parties.
1990年3月15日至1991年12月31日期间,我们收治了弗吉尼亚梅森医院连续175例因孤立性冠状动脉搭桥手术入院的慢性稳定性心绞痛患者,这些患者之前均接受过冠状动脉造影。100例患者在手术当天入院,75例被认为风险较高的患者在手术前1天入院。所有患者的术后进展均通过临床路径表进行监测,该表记录了生理指标和活动指标与术后天数的关系。我们发现患者在年龄、性别或合并症因素总数方面没有差异。糖尿病和射血分数低于0.50在术前入院的患者中更为常见,并且是入院分组的独立预测因素。不同外科医生收治的当日入院患者比例存在显著差异,这无法用常见风险因素的差异来解释。术后主要或次要并发症的发生率或临床路径偏离的数量没有显著差异,但术前入院的患者中有2例死亡。当日入院患者的平均总住院天数少1.5天,这是一个非常显著的差异。该系列患者的平均总住院费用为19,000美元,术前入院患者的费用平均高出286美元,这一差异无统计学意义。选择性当日进行冠状动脉搭桥手术的患者并发症数量不会增加。虽然他们的住院时间缩短了,但住院费用的降低幅度很小。对于需要药物治疗或身体残疾的合并症患者,术前入院仍然是合理的,入院决策应由主刀医生做出,而不是第三方。