Hastings H, Weiss A P, Strickland J W
Indiana University School of Medicine, Indiana Hand Center, Indianapolis.
Orthopade. 1993 Feb;22(1):86-91.
Three studies conducted in our center demonstrated an improved technical success rate and elimination of preoperative pain in patients undergoing wrist fusions, with no significant difference in the ability to perform rapid movements requiring manual dexterity in the course of activities of daily living compared with patients who had undergone motion-preserving limited arthrodeses. The only absolute drawback of wrist fusion is that it obviously does not allow for any wrist motion at all. Limited intercarpal arthrodesis preserves some motion, but according to our results never leads to increased motion postoperatively. Several specific skills were found to present difficulty in patients who had undergone total wrist fusion. These included those requiring volar flexion in a limited space, where it would be difficult to have recourse to compensatory motion imparted by the shoulder and elbow, and those requiring forceful pronation and supination with simultaneous strong grasping. For patients involved in certain occupations requiring fine manual dexterity in tight spaces, wrist fusion might not be the most appropriate procedure. It is interesting that there appears to be a learning curve to the patient's ability to undertake specific activities postoperatively. A strong practice effect is present for the first 3-6 postoperative months, during which time a significant improvement in the patient's overall function is noted. Total wrist arthrodesis gives highly predictable results in the treatment of wrist pain and instability. The ability to perform normal activities of daily living and strenuous manual tasks was comparable to that after alternative motion-preserving procedures. We have not observed improved wrist motion after any wrist motion-preserving procedure.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
我们中心进行的三项研究表明,接受腕关节融合术的患者技术成功率提高,术前疼痛消除,与接受保留运动的有限关节固定术的患者相比,在日常生活活动中进行需要手部灵巧性的快速动作的能力没有显著差异。腕关节融合术唯一绝对的缺点是它显然完全不允许腕关节有任何活动。腕骨间有限关节固定术保留了一些运动,但根据我们的结果,术后从未导致运动增加。我们发现,接受全腕关节融合术的患者在一些特定技能方面存在困难。这些技能包括在有限空间内需要掌屈的动作,此时很难借助肩部和肘部的代偿动作,以及需要强力旋前和旋后同时用力抓握的动作。对于某些需要在狭小空间内进行精细手部灵巧操作的职业患者,腕关节融合术可能不是最合适的手术。有趣的是,患者术后进行特定活动的能力似乎存在学习曲线。术后前3至6个月存在强烈的练习效应,在此期间患者的整体功能有显著改善。全腕关节融合术在治疗腕关节疼痛和不稳定方面能产生高度可预测的结果。进行日常生活正常活动和繁重体力任务的能力与其他保留运动的手术相当。我们没有观察到任何保留腕关节运动的手术后腕关节运动得到改善。(摘要截短至250字)