Griffith M J, Bexton R S, McComb J M
Cardiac Department, Freeman Hospital, Newcastle upon Tyne.
Br Heart J. 1993 Mar;69(3):272-5. doi: 10.1136/hrt.69.3.272.
To assess the financial implications of antitachycardia pacing in patients with frequent supraventricular tachycardia.
Intertach pacemakers were implanted in 25 patients (mean age 47 years, five men): 22 had atrioventricular nodal reentry tachycardia. The patients had failed a mean of 4.9 (range zero to eight) drugs and had been admitted to hospital 3.7 (zero to 31) times over a symptomatic period of 13.9 years (two months to 54 years).
The mean admission time for implantation was 2.8 (two to seven) days. One patient with Wolff-Parkinson-White syndrome subsequently underwent surgery. Infection occurred in two patients, and pain over the pacemaker required its resiting in two. Two patients have had one admission each for tachycardia. Six patients remain on anti-arrhythmic drugs. Costs were calculated including value added tax, capital charges, and allocated overheads. The cost a year before pacing was 1174 pounds including drug costs, clinic visits, and hospital admissions. The mean cost of pacemaker implantation was 3364.22 pounds, including the pacemaker and lead, admission and procedure, readmissions and first pacing check. Subsequent annual follow up cost was 73.72 pounds including annual clinic visits and drug costs. The cost of pacing is 4241 pounds whereas medical management costs 7044 pounds assuming pacemaker life of six years: with a 10 year life the cost is 4537 pounds compared with 11,740 pounds: with a 12 year life the cost is 4685 pounds compared with 14,088 pounds.
The excess cost of implantation of an antitachycardia pacemaker is minimal in patients with frequent supraventricular tachycardia despite drug treatment and is justified by excellent control of symptoms and reduction of drug use and hospital admissions.
评估频繁室上性心动过速患者抗心动过速起搏的财务影响。
25例患者(平均年龄47岁,5例男性)植入了心动过速间期起搏器:22例患有房室结折返性心动过速。这些患者平均试用了4.9种(范围为0至8种)药物均无效,在13.9年(2个月至54年)的症状期内平均住院3.7次(0至31次)。
植入的平均住院时间为2.8天(2至7天)。1例预激综合征患者随后接受了手术。2例患者发生感染,2例因起搏器部位疼痛需要重新放置。2例患者因心动过速各住院1次。6例患者仍在服用抗心律失常药物。计算成本时包括增值税、资本费用和分摊的间接费用。起搏前一年的成本为1174英镑,包括药物费用、门诊就诊和住院费用。起搏器植入的平均成本为3364.22英镑,包括起搏器和导线、住院和手术、再次入院和首次起搏检查。随后每年的随访成本为73.72英镑,包括年度门诊就诊和药物费用。假设起搏器使用寿命为6年,起搏成本为4241英镑,而药物治疗成本为7044英镑:使用寿命为10年时,成本为4537英镑,而药物治疗成本为11740英镑:使用寿命为12年时,成本为4685英镑,而药物治疗成本为14088英镑。
尽管进行了药物治疗,但对于频繁室上性心动过速患者,植入抗心动过速起搏器的额外成本极低,且因其对症状的良好控制以及药物使用和住院次数的减少而合理。