Lutjens L R
Kirkhof School of Nursing, Grand Valley State University, Allendale, MI.
J Nurs Adm. 1993 Apr;23(4):14-8. doi: 10.1097/00005110-199304000-00003.
An example of the inefficiency of cost-based reimbursement is that wide variations were observed between hospitals and between regions in the cost of treating similar diagnoses, with no apparent differences in quality. To correct these variations, the Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act and its concomitant prospective payment system based on DRGs was implemented. However, wide variations continued to exist among hospitals and regions in the United States. The attempt by the medical profession to refine the prospective payment system by severity adjustments has received lukewarm support. The work by Halloran et al on the relationship between nursing diagnosis and length of stay shows some promise. Studies on nursing intensity have produced mixed results. Recently, the Prospective Payment Assessment Commission decided to discontinue efforts to develop nursing intensity adjustments for DRG weights. Additionally, institutional characteristics, except for discharge planning programs, and patient characteristics have exhibited mixed results in attempts to explain hospital length of stay. Concern over continuing variations that DRGs and their proposed adjustments have been unable to correct led to the formation of the Agency for Healthcare Policy and Research, which was brought about by the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1989. This agency seems to believe that practice patterns offer the greatest hope of reducing excessive hospital lengths of stay and concomitant costs.
基于成本的报销方式效率低下的一个例子是,在治疗相似诊断的费用方面,不同医院之间以及不同地区之间存在很大差异,而质量却没有明显差异。为了纠正这些差异,实施了《税收公平与财政责任法》及其基于诊断相关分组(DRGs)的配套前瞻性支付系统。然而,美国的医院和地区之间仍然存在很大差异。医学专业人士试图通过病情严重程度调整来完善前瞻性支付系统,但得到的支持并不热烈。哈洛兰等人关于护理诊断与住院时间之间关系的研究显示出了一些希望。关于护理强度的研究结果喜忧参半。最近,前瞻性支付评估委员会决定停止为诊断相关分组权重制定护理强度调整的工作。此外,除出院计划项目外,机构特征以及患者特征在解释医院住院时间的尝试中结果不一。对诊断相关分组及其提议的调整未能纠正的持续差异的担忧,导致了医疗保健政策与研究机构的成立,这是由1989年的《综合预算协调法》促成的。该机构似乎认为,实践模式最有希望减少过长的医院住院时间及随之而来的成本。