Bischoff P, Kochs E, Droese D, Meyer-Moldenhauer W H, Schulte am Esch J
Abteilung für Anästhesiologie, Universitäts-Krankenhaus Eppendorf, Hamburg.
Anaesthesist. 1993 Mar;42(3):142-8.
Increases in slow-wave (delta) activity in the EEG may reflect increased depth of anaesthesia provided that hypoxia, haemodynamic instability and drug overdose have been excluded. In contrast, similar intraoperative EEG responses have been described as paradoxical arousal reactions. The aim of this study was to assess the effects of surgical stimulation on spatial EEG changes during anaesthesia with 0.6% isoflurane/66% nitrous oxide. METHODS. The present study investigated changes in EEG power and frequencies in 20 patients (mean age 36 +/- 8 years; ASA I or II) scheduled for elective urological surgery during steady-state anaesthesia with 0.6% isoflurane and 66% nitrous oxide. The following variables were measured: heart rate (HR), mean arterial blood pressure (MAP), end-tidal isoflurane (PetISO) and carbon dioxide concentrations (PetCO2), arterial oxygen saturation (SaO2%) and body temperature (degree C). Patients were randomly assigned to one of two groups: group 1 (n = 10; without surgery) and group 2 (n = 10; with surgical procedure). The EEG was recorded over 20 min. The first 5 min were taken as baseline. In group 2 surgical stimulation (skin incision with subsequent surgical preparation) was started 1-2 min after recording of baseline values. Topographical distribution of EEG output was recorded from 17 electrodes (international 10-20 system), digitized and stored on disk (CATEEM) after establishment of steady-state anaesthesia (PetISO: 0.6%; PetCO2: 35-37 mmHg). Data are given as medium (microV2/Hz) and relative changes (%) +/- SD with respect to baseline. Statistical significance was tested for F4 versus C4 for the delta- and alpha-1-frequency bands using Wilcoxon's test (P < 0.05). RESULTS. In group 1 (without surgical stimulation) all parameters did not change over time. EEG slowing with an increase in power (> 100%) was noted in 8 patients of group 2 (n = 10; during surgical stimulation). By visual inspection of the original EEG tracings paradoxical arousal patterns were seen in these patients. In group 2, delta output changed from 69.6 microV2/Hz (baseline) to 147.4 microV2/Hz at frontal leads (F4) 5-6 min after the start of surgery. Only minimal changes were observed for theta activity. At the same time, in most cases fast wave activity (alpha 1, alpha 2, beta 1 and beta 2) was decreased by more than 50% at identical cortical areas. Increases in MAP were noted continuously after start of surgery up to a maximum of 19.8% from baseline, which became significant at the 16-min level. Heart rate did not change over time. DISCUSSION. Our data demonstrate that EEG slowing may be induced by surgical stimulation during steady-state anaesthesia with 0.6% isoflurane/66% nitrous oxide in oxygen. These findings are consistent with previous reports indicating the occurrence of slow wave patterns following sensory stimulation in comatose patients. Since these events occur predominantly at frontal areas they may not be detected with single-channel parietal recordings. Our data suggest that topographical EEG monitoring may useful for assessing painful events during surgery. Using EEG monoparameters like spectral edge frequency or median the occurrence of paradoxical arousal reactions may be falsely interpreted as an increased depth of anaesthesia.
脑电图中慢波(δ波)活动的增加可能反映麻醉深度的增加,前提是已排除缺氧、血流动力学不稳定和药物过量的情况。相比之下,类似的术中脑电图反应被描述为反常觉醒反应。本研究的目的是评估在使用0.6%异氟醚/66%氧化亚氮麻醉期间手术刺激对脑电图空间变化的影响。方法:本研究调查了20例计划进行择期泌尿外科手术的患者(平均年龄36±8岁;美国麻醉医师协会I或II级)在使用0.6%异氟醚和66%氧化亚氮进行稳态麻醉期间脑电图功率和频率的变化。测量了以下变量:心率(HR)、平均动脉血压(MAP)、呼气末异氟醚(PetISO)和二氧化碳浓度(PetCO2)、动脉血氧饱和度(SaO2%)和体温(摄氏度)。患者被随机分为两组之一:第1组(n = 10;无手术)和第2组(n = 10;有手术操作)。脑电图记录20分钟。前5分钟作为基线。在第2组中,在记录基线值后1 - 2分钟开始手术刺激(皮肤切开并随后进行手术准备)。在建立稳态麻醉(PetISO:0.6%;PetCO2:35 - 37 mmHg)后,从17个电极(国际10 - 20系统)记录脑电图输出的地形分布,数字化并存储在磁盘上(CATEEM)。数据以相对于基线的中位数(μV2/Hz)和相对变化(%)±标准差表示。使用Wilcoxon检验(P < 0.05)对δ波和α1频段的F4与C4进行统计学显著性检验。结果:在第1组(无手术刺激)中,所有参数随时间均无变化。在第2组的8例患者(n = 10;在手术刺激期间)中观察到脑电图减慢且功率增加(> 100%)。通过目视检查原始脑电图记录,在这些患者中发现了反常觉醒模式。在第2组中,手术开始后5 - 6分钟,额叶导联(F4)处的δ波输出从69.6μV2/Hz(基线)变为147.4μV2/Hz。θ波活动仅观察到最小变化。同时,在大多数情况下,相同皮质区域的快波活动(α1、α2、β1和β2)减少超过50%。手术开始后MAP持续升高,最高比基线升高19.8%,在16分钟时变得显著。心率随时间无变化。讨论:我们的数据表明,在使用0.6%异氟醚/66%氧化亚氮在氧气中进行稳态麻醉期间,手术刺激可能诱发脑电图减慢。这些发现与先前的报告一致,表明昏迷患者在感觉刺激后会出现慢波模式。由于这些事件主要发生在额叶区域,单通道顶叶记录可能无法检测到。我们的数据表明,脑电图地形监测可能有助于评估手术期间的疼痛事件。使用诸如频谱边缘频率或中位数等脑电图单参数,反常觉醒反应的发生可能被错误地解释为麻醉深度增加。