Melton L J, Lane A W, Cooper C, Eastell R, O'Fallon W M, Riggs B L
Department of Health Sciences Research, Mayo Clinic and Foundation, Rochester, Minnesota 55905.
Osteoporos Int. 1993 May;3(3):113-9. doi: 10.1007/BF01623271.
There is a need to identify vertebral fractures from radiographs taken at a single point in time, but considerable controversy surrounds the methods to be used. We extended a data set to comprise baseline radiographs of the thoracic and lumbar spine on an age-stratified random sample of 762 Rochester, Minnesota, women and used revised methods to define vertebral deformities morphometrically. Changes in the method of measuring vertebral heights, changes in the source of normal values for vertebral measurements and changes in the criteria for assessing vertebral deformity had little impact on estimated prevalence and incidence in this population. The prevalence of any vertebral deformity was estimated at 25.3 per 100 Rochester women aged 50 years and over (95% CI, 22.3-28.2), while the incidence of a new deformity in this group was estimated at 17.8 per 1000 person-years (95% CI, 16.0-19.7). Projected nationally, these data suggest that over 500,000 white women in the United States develop vertebral deformities for the first time each year and that over 7 million white women aged 50 years and over might be affected at any given time. These estimates are limited by the absence of a reliable 'gold standard' with which to determine false positive and false negative rates associated with this or any other morphometric method. Information on the health consequences of vertebral deformities of various sorts would be most helpful in choosing between alternative approaches to defining them.
需要从某一时刻拍摄的X光片中识别椎体骨折,但对于应采用的方法存在相当大的争议。我们扩充了一个数据集,纳入了明尼苏达州罗切斯特市762名女性按年龄分层的随机样本的胸腰椎基线X光片,并使用修订后的方法从形态学上定义椎体畸形。测量椎体高度方法的改变、椎体测量正常值来源的改变以及评估椎体畸形标准的改变,对该人群中估计的患病率和发病率影响不大。估计每100名年龄在50岁及以上的罗切斯特女性中,任何椎体畸形的患病率为25.3(95%可信区间,22.3 - 28.2),而该组中新发畸形的发病率估计为每1000人年17.8(95%可信区间,16.0 - 19.7)。在全国范围内进行推算,这些数据表明,美国每年有超过50万白人女性首次出现椎体畸形,且在任何给定时间,可能有超过700万50岁及以上的白人女性受到影响。这些估计因缺乏可靠的“金标准”而受到限制,无法确定与这种或任何其他形态学方法相关的假阳性和假阴性率。关于各种椎体畸形对健康影响的信息,对于在定义椎体畸形的替代方法之间做出选择将非常有帮助。