Calkins H, Lehmann M H, Allman K, Wieland D, Schwaiger M
Division of Cardiology, University of Michigan Medical Center, Ann Arbor.
Circulation. 1993 May;87(5):1616-21. doi: 10.1161/01.cir.87.5.1616.
The purpose of this study was to determine whether scintigraphic evidence of cardiac sympathetic neuronal dysinnervation is present in patients with the familial long QT syndrome. The "sympathetic imbalance" hypothesis for the familial long QT syndrome proposes that the long QT syndrome results from a congenital imbalance of sympathetic innervation of the heart caused by lower-than-normal right cardiac sympathetic activity. Although the majority of clinical features of the long QT syndrome can be understood according to this hypothesis, its validity has never been shown. Noninvasive scintigraphic evaluation of the pattern of sympathetic innervation of the heart has recently become possible with catecholamine analogues that can be taken up by sympathetic nerve terminals: radioiodinated metaiodobenzyl guanidine or C-11 hydroxyephedrine (HED).
Nine affected patients, each from a separate family with familial long QT syndrome, were enrolled in this study (three men, six women; mean age, 39 +/- 16 years). Scintigraphic evaluation of the pattern of cardiac sympathetic innervation in each patient was performed with HED in conjunction with positron emission tomography. The results of scintigraphic imaging in these patients were compared with those obtained in 14 asymptomatic volunteers. Scintigraphic evaluation demonstrated that HED retention index and HED uptake normalized to blood flow were no different in patients with the familial long QT syndrome than in normal control patients.
Patients with the long QT syndrome have normal cardiac sympathetic innervation as assessed by HED. This finding, although not incompatible with the sympathetic imbalance hypothesis of the long QT syndrome, suggests that if a decrease in right sympathetic activity is present in patients with familial long QT syndrome, it is unlikely to be attributed to an abnormal distribution of cardiac sympathetic nerves.
本研究的目的是确定家族性长QT综合征患者是否存在心脏交感神经去神经支配的闪烁显像证据。家族性长QT综合征的“交感神经失衡”假说提出,长QT综合征是由右心交感神经活动低于正常水平导致的先天性心脏交感神经支配失衡引起的。尽管根据这一假说可以理解长QT综合征的大多数临床特征,但其有效性从未得到证实。最近,利用可被交感神经末梢摄取的儿茶酚胺类似物:放射性碘标记的间碘苄胍或C-11羟基麻黄碱(HED),对心脏交感神经支配模式进行无创闪烁显像评估已成为可能。
本研究纳入了9例受影响的患者,每例来自一个独立的家族性长QT综合征家族(3名男性,6名女性;平均年龄39±16岁)。使用HED结合正电子发射断层扫描对每位患者的心脏交感神经支配模式进行闪烁显像评估。将这些患者的闪烁显像结果与14名无症状志愿者的结果进行比较。闪烁显像评估表明,家族性长QT综合征患者的HED保留指数和HED摄取与血流归一化后与正常对照患者无差异。
通过HED评估,长QT综合征患者的心脏交感神经支配正常。这一发现虽然与长QT综合征的交感神经失衡假说并不矛盾,但表明如果家族性长QT综合征患者存在右交感神经活动降低的情况,不太可能归因于心脏交感神经的异常分布。