Byard R W, Hucker S J, Hazelwood R R
Department of Histopathology, Adelaide Children's Hospital, Australia.
Am J Forensic Med Pathol. 1993 Mar;14(1):70-3. doi: 10.1097/00000433-199303000-00017.
As asphyxial episodes during autoerotic activity are rarely reported in women, a review of eight fatal cases and one near-fatal case was conducted to delineate more clearly the characteristics of this syndrome in women. Six cases involved characteristic fatal autoerotic asphyxial activity. The remaining two fatal cases were atypical in that the apparatus that was used for sexual purposes was not intended to cause asphyxia in one case and did not directly cause asphyxial death in the second case. The final case was not fatal. Significantly, the majority of women did not use unusual clothing, props, or devices to augment their activity, for example, five were completely naked and only one was found with elaborate clothing and extra ligatures. Six of the fatal cases had objective evidence of sexual activity, three had used neck padding to prevent chafing, and eight had failed self-rescue mechanisms. Of note, the initial impression in four cases (44%) was homicide (two), attempted suicide (one), and accidental death during sexual activity with a partner (one). These results support the assertion that the manifestations of female autoerotic asphyxial activity reported to date may be initially misleading to investigators. Our purpose in presenting these findings, therefore, is to increase awareness of the more subtle features of this syndrome in women in an attempt to reduce the potential for underdiagnosis or confusion with nonaccidental death in future cases.
由于女性在自慰活动中发生窒息事件的报道很少,因此对八例致命病例和一例近乎致命的病例进行了回顾,以更清楚地描述该综合征在女性中的特征。六例涉及典型的致命自慰窒息活动。其余两例致命病例不典型,其中一例用于性目的的器具并非旨在导致窒息,另一例未直接导致窒息死亡。最后一例未致命。值得注意的是,大多数女性并未使用特殊的衣物、道具或装置来增强其活动,例如,五例完全裸体,仅一例被发现穿着精致且有额外的捆绑物。六例致命病例有性行为的客观证据,三例使用了颈部衬垫以防止擦伤,八例自救机制失效。值得注意的是,四例(44%)的初步印象是他杀(两例)、自杀未遂(一例)以及与伴侣性行为时意外死亡(一例)。这些结果支持了这样一种观点,即迄今为止报道的女性自慰窒息活动的表现可能最初会误导调查人员。因此,我们呈现这些发现的目的是提高对该综合征在女性中更细微特征的认识,以试图减少未来病例中漏诊或与非意外死亡混淆的可能性。