Evans R W
School of Dental Science, University of Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
J Dent Res. 1993 May;72(5):883-90. doi: 10.1177/00220345930720050901.
The objectives of this study were: (1) to develop and test a new index, the Chronological Fluorosis Assessment (CFA) Index, for measuring variation in the chronological distribution and intensity of dental fluorosis, and (2) to determine whether the new index was sufficiently sensitive for detection of a decline in dental fluorosis corresponding to the reduction in the waterborne fluoride level in Hong Kong. According to the CFA Index, the cervical, middle, and incisal third divisions of the labial surface of a maxillary central incisor crown are each classified into one of six categories of an ordinal scale of fluorosis. Data from 1295 life-long resident Hong Kong Chinese children exposed to known water fluoride concentrations were analyzed. Fluorosis declined from incisal to cervical in 41% of cases, and a reverse gradient was apparent in 29%. Overall, fluorosis intensity was higher on incisal thirds than on both middle and cervical thirds. However, when tooth thirds were regrouped according to common 16-month developmental periods, in order to control for time-related variation in fluoride concentration, the incisal-middle difference was of reduced statistical significance, and both the incisal-cervical and the middle-cervical differences became insignificant. A regression analysis of CFA Index on cohort indicated a significant cohort-related fluorosis decrease, in relation to cervical, middle, and incisal tooth thirds. It was concluded (1) that fluorosed enamel which forms in chronological sequence tends toward a uniform intensity, and (2) that the new index was sufficiently sensitive for a decline to be measured in dental fluorosis in Hong Kong.
(1)开发并测试一种新的指数——按时间顺序排列的氟斑牙评估(CFA)指数,用于测量氟斑牙按时间顺序分布和严重程度的变化;(2)确定该新指数对于检测香港地区与饮用水氟含量降低相对应的氟斑牙减少是否足够敏感。根据CFA指数,上颌中切牙唇面的颈、中、切三分之一部分分别被分为氟斑牙顺序量表的六个类别之一。分析了1295名已知暴露于不同饮用水氟浓度的香港华裔常住儿童的数据。41%的病例中氟斑牙从切端向颈部递减,29%的病例中呈现相反的梯度。总体而言,切三分之一处的氟斑牙严重程度高于中三分之一和颈三分之一处。然而,当根据常见的16个月发育阶段重新分组牙的三分之一部分,以控制氟浓度与时间相关的变化时,切端与中间的差异在统计学上的显著性降低,切端与颈部以及中间与颈部的差异均变得不显著。对CFA指数进行的队列回归分析表明,与颈、中、切牙三分之一部分相关的氟斑牙有显著的队列相关减少。得出的结论是:(1)按时间顺序形成的氟斑牙釉质倾向于具有均匀的严重程度;(2)新指数对于测量香港地区氟斑牙的减少足够敏感。