Griffiths R R, Evans S M, Guarino J J, Roache J D, Furman W R, Liebson I, Schwam E M
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland.
J Pharmacol Exp Ther. 1993 Jun;265(3):1163-74.
The effects of i.v. administered flumazenil (3.0 mg) were studied in healthy male subjects who received pretreatment with p.o. placebo or lorazepam. The duration of placebo or lorazepam (3.0 mg single p.o. daily dose) pretreatment before a flumazenil or placebo injection was 1, 3, 7 or 14 days in four sequential groups of subjects. Initial administration of lorazepam produced a classic sedative profile of effects on various psychomotor/behavioral performance, observer-rated and subject-rated measures. Tolerance to repeated daily administration of lorazepam was suggested by a progressive diminution of performance disrupting effects. In subjects pretreated with placebo, flumazenil increased subject-ratings of dizziness over preinjection ratings. Flumazenil produced an immediate reversal of lorazepam effects in subjects who were not tolerant to lorazepam (1- and 3-day pretreatment groups). Flumazenil did not precipitate withdrawal symptoms in subjects who received a single administration of lorazepam. Precipitated withdrawal symptoms were evident after 3 and 7 days of lorazepam pretreatment, and there was a tendency toward precipitated withdrawal symptoms (that included one panic attack) after 14 days of lorazepam pretreatment. Precipitated withdrawal was characterized by an elevation in subject-rated symptoms including dizziness, tenseness, tachycardia, perceptual disturbance and sweating. Symptoms were maximal immediately after injection, usually mild in severity and usually resolved within 1 hr. There was no evidence of precipitated withdrawal on psychomotor/behavioral performance or observer ratings. The present study provides the strongest human experimental evidence to date that flumazenil can precipitate withdrawal symptoms after a history of repeated benzodiazepine exposure.
在接受口服安慰剂或劳拉西泮预处理的健康男性受试者中,研究了静脉注射氟马西尼(3.0毫克)的效果。在四组连续的受试者中,在注射氟马西尼或安慰剂之前,安慰剂或劳拉西泮(每日口服单剂量3.0毫克)的预处理持续时间分别为1、3、7或14天。初始给予劳拉西泮对各种精神运动/行为表现、观察者评分和受试者评分指标产生了典型的镇静作用。对劳拉西泮每日重复给药的耐受性表现为其对行为的干扰作用逐渐减弱。在接受安慰剂预处理的受试者中,氟马西尼使受试者对头晕的评分高于注射前评分。氟马西尼在对劳拉西泮不耐受的受试者(1天和3天预处理组)中立即逆转了劳拉西泮的作用。氟马西尼在接受单次劳拉西泮给药的受试者中未引发戒断症状。在劳拉西泮预处理3天和7天后,明显出现了戒断症状,在劳拉西泮预处理14天后有出现戒断症状的趋势(包括一次惊恐发作)。戒断症状的特征是受试者评分的症状升高,包括头晕、紧张、心动过速、感知障碍和出汗。症状在注射后立即达到最大值,严重程度通常较轻,通常在1小时内缓解。没有证据表明在精神运动/行为表现或观察者评分方面出现了戒断症状。本研究提供了迄今为止最有力的人体实验证据,表明在有反复接触苯二氮䓬类药物史后,氟马西尼可引发戒断症状。