Wroblewski B M, Siney P D
Centre for Hip Surgery, Wrightington Hospital, Wigan, Lancashire, United Kingdom.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1993 Jul(292):191-201.
Charnley low-friction arthroplasty (LFA) has become the method of choice for patients with destroyed arthritic hip joints; the authors' 18-26-year observation suggests that LFA could be considered the gold standard for total hip arthroplasty (THA). The continuity of concept, design, and the surgical technique extends beyond 29 years and offers predictability of outcome. Fatal postoperative pulmonary embolism, initially at 0.7% within one year of surgery, shows significant seasonal variation and as yet unexplained declining incidence. Incidence of dislocation is 0.63%, with a 0.11% chance of revision. The incidence of deep infection is 0.3%-1.5% in primary surgery and varies with the underlying hip pathology. Introduction of the intramedullary bone block has reduced the revision rate for stem loosening to less than 1% at 14 years and completely eliminated stem fracture. There has not been a fracture of a recently manufactured stem (Ortron). Revision for socket loosening has been reduced to 3% by the introduction of the ogee-flanged socket. The outcome of the socket survivorship is determined by the depth of socket penetration, the relationship between the two being exponential. Because the socket demarcation and migration are usually asymptomatic, the timing of revision would be determined by the surgeon's awareness of the problem. Repeated revisions produce conditions almost comparable to a locally malignant condition: dwindling bone stock, increasing implant size, local recurrence of the problem. Accumulation of the experience with the Charnley LFA has been shown to benefit both old and young patients.
查恩利低摩擦关节成形术(LFA)已成为髋关节破坏的关节炎患者的首选治疗方法;作者长达18至26年的观察表明,LFA可被视为全髋关节置换术(THA)的金标准。其概念、设计和手术技术的连贯性超过了29年,且能提供可预测的结果。术后致命性肺栓塞最初在术后一年内的发生率为0.7%,呈现出显著的季节性变化,且发病率下降原因尚不明。脱位发生率为0.63%,翻修概率为0.11%。初次手术中深部感染的发生率为0.3% - 1.5%,并随潜在的髋关节病变而变化。髓内骨块的引入已将柄松动的翻修率在14年时降至1%以下,并完全消除了柄骨折。最近生产的柄(奥创)未出现骨折情况。通过引入S形凸缘髋臼杯,髋臼杯松动的翻修率已降至3%。髋臼杯的留存结果取决于髋臼杯的植入深度,二者关系呈指数相关。由于髋臼杯的分界和移位通常无症状,翻修时机将由外科医生对该问题的认知来决定。反复翻修会产生几乎与局部恶性病变相当的情况:骨量减少、植入物尺寸增大、问题局部复发。事实证明,积累查恩利LFA的经验对老年和年轻患者均有益。