Pumps and warmers during amnioinfusion: is either necessary?

OBJECTIVE

To determine if there is evidence from published reports that the use of infusion pumps or solution warmers during amnioinfusion is beneficial.

DATA SOURCES

We identified all English-language amnioinfusion reports published since 1983 through Medline and references.

METHODS OF STUDY SELECTION

Fourteen prospective papers with at least 40 subjects were identified.

DATA EXTRACTION AND SYNTHESIS

For the amnioinfusion and control groups in each study, odds ratios (OR) were calculated for cesarean delivery, fetal distress, meconium below the cords, low 5-minute Apgar score, and endometritis. Cumulative ORs were calculated using the Mantel-Haenszel inverse variance method. This process was repeated after separation into pump-gravity and warmed-unwarmed groups. Multiple regression analyses were performed. Amnioinfusion improved the ability of the fetus to tolerate labor (fetal distress OR 0.40), decreased the incidence of meconium below the cords (OR 0.16), and decreased the rate of cesarean delivery (OR 0.56). There were no demonstrable benefits associated with the use of warmers or pumps. In multiple regression analysis, infusion pumps were associated with a significantly increased risk of fetal distress (P = .01).

CONCLUSION

The use of amnioinfusion is associated with a decreased risk of fetal distress, meconium below the cords, and cesarean delivery. To date, there is no demonstrable benefit using infusion pumps or solution warmers during amnioinfusion.