Djindjian M, Raulo Y, Gaston A, Decq P, Gabriel-Cordonnier E, Poirier J, Keravel Y
Service de Neurochirurgie, Hôpital Henri Mondor, Créteil.
Neurochirurgie. 1995;41(5):329-36.
Between 1982 and 1993, 11 cases of intra-extracranial vault meningiomas were treated in Créteil, by the same multidisciplinary team. The average age was 53.5 years and the Karnofsky rating was high (> 80 in 7 cases). Ten of the 11 cases had medial tumours with venous sinus thrombosis occurring in 9 of these. The location of the tumour was frontal in 6 and parietal in 4 patients. Of the medial tumours, 5 (half) were bilateral intracranial lesions. The average duration of symptoms was more than 10 years in four cases, between 1 and 3 years in five, and the diagnosis was made immediately in two patients. MRI coronal sections, after venous contrast injection, allowed diagnosis of the lesion and visualisation of the sinus thrombosis. Embolisation was performed pre-operatively in all cases scheduled to have surgery, resulting in safe excision of the tumour. Surgery was performed in 9 patients with complete tumour removal achieved in 8. Of those who did not undergo surgery, one received radiotherapy and the other died before treatment. The bony defect was covered with cadaveric bone, autogenous bone, coral and methyl-methacrylate in one, two, two and two patients respectively. Complications occurred in 2 cases: extradural secondary infection and CSF rhinorrhea treated with a lumbo-peritoneal shunt. The post-operative Karnofsky rating was greater than 90 in seven cases, 70 in one, and 50 in two cases. After an average follow-up of 4 years, 3 patients had tumor recurrence at 4, 7, and 8 years; the first having a locally malignant character, the second showing radiological recurrence in a case of subtotal removal, and the third a marginal recurrence. Two of the 3 patients underwent further surgery. The malignant case, received radiotherapy but unfortunately a new recurrence occurred 14 months later. As radiotherapy was used in only 3 cases, statistically significant conclusions concerning efficacy cannot be drawn.
1982年至1993年间,同一多学科团队在克雷泰伊治疗了11例颅内外硬脑膜瘤。平均年龄为53.5岁,卡氏评分较高(7例>80分)。11例中有10例为内侧肿瘤,其中9例发生静脉窦血栓形成。肿瘤位于额叶6例,顶叶4例。在内侧肿瘤中,5例(半数)为双侧颅内病变。4例患者症状平均持续时间超过10年,5例在1至3年之间,2例患者立即确诊。静脉注射造影剂后的MRI冠状位切片可诊断病变并显示静脉窦血栓形成。所有计划手术的病例均在术前进行了栓塞,从而实现了肿瘤的安全切除。9例患者接受了手术,8例实现了肿瘤完全切除。未接受手术的患者中,1例接受了放疗,另1例在治疗前死亡。分别有1例、2例、2例和2例患者用尸体骨、自体骨、珊瑚和甲基丙烯酸甲酯覆盖骨缺损。发生了2例并发症:硬膜外继发感染和脑脊液鼻漏,通过腰大池腹腔分流术进行治疗。术后卡氏评分7例大于90分,1例为70分,2例为50分。平均随访4年后,3例患者分别在4年、7年和8年出现肿瘤复发;第一例具有局部恶性特征,第二例在次全切除病例中出现影像学复发,第三例为边缘复发。3例患者中有2例接受了进一步手术。恶性病例接受了放疗,但不幸的是14个月后出现了新的复发。由于仅3例使用了放疗,因此无法得出关于疗效的具有统计学意义的结论。