Mayeaux E J, Davis T C, Jackson R H, Henry D, Patton P, Slay L, Sentell T
Department of Family Medicine, Louisiana State University Medical Center, Shreveport, USA.
Fam Med. 1995 Nov-Dec;27(10):658-62.
Because of its brevity and ease of use, the Mini-mental State Examination (MMSE) is commonly used to screen and follow patients with cognitive impairment. This pilot study attempted to determine the relationships between literacy, age, and self-reported educational level and the total MMSE score.
Cross-sectional analysis of all patients was followed by a family practice group at five local nursing homes. The associations between the patients' MMSE scores; literacy, as measured by the Rapid Estimate of Adult Literacy in Medicine (REALM); self-reported educational level; and age were determined using Pearson's correlation coefficient and stepwise multivariate linear regression.
A total of 105 patients completed the study. Linear regression analysis showed that MMSE scores were significantly predicted by REALM score (P < .001) and the patient's age (P < .02). However, after accounting for REALM score and age, the self-reported educational level was not related to the MMSE score (P < .8). A significant relationship was seen between the REALM score and the subjects' self-reported educational levels (r = .44, P < .001) but not the subjects' ages (r = -.17, P < 0.09). A significant linear correlation was found between the MMSE and REALM scores (r = .71, P < .0001) and a significant inverse correlation was seen between MMSE scores and the patients' ages (r = -.28, P < .004). The correlation coefficient between the patients' MMSE scores and the self-reported educational levels was .33 (P < .0007).
Practitioners who rely on the MMSE should be aware that patients may score in the demented range because they cannot read well enough to accurately complete the test. Literacy testing with REALM or other instruments may help identify such patients.
由于简易精神状态检查表(MMSE)简短且易于使用,常用于筛查和跟踪认知障碍患者。本试点研究试图确定读写能力、年龄、自我报告的教育水平与MMSE总分之间的关系。
对当地五家养老院家庭医疗组的所有患者进行横断面分析。使用Pearson相关系数和逐步多元线性回归确定患者MMSE评分、通过医学成人读写能力快速评估(REALM)测量的读写能力、自我报告的教育水平和年龄之间的关联。
共有105名患者完成了研究。线性回归分析表明,MMSE评分由REALM评分(P <.001)和患者年龄(P <.02)显著预测。然而,在考虑REALM评分和年龄后,自我报告的教育水平与MMSE评分无关(P <.8)。REALM评分与受试者自我报告的教育水平之间存在显著关系(r =.44,P <.001),但与受试者年龄无关(r = -.17,P <0.09)。MMSE与REALM评分之间存在显著线性相关性(r =.71,P <.0001),MMSE评分与患者年龄之间存在显著负相关性(r = -.28,P <.004)。患者MMSE评分与自我报告的教育水平之间的相关系数为.33(P <.0007)。
依赖MMSE的从业者应意识到,患者可能因阅读能力不足无法准确完成测试而在痴呆范围内得分。使用REALM或其他工具进行读写能力测试可能有助于识别此类患者。