Wanklyn P, Cox N, Belfield P
Medical Department for the Elderly, Leeds General Infirmary.
Age Ageing. 1995 Nov;24(6):510-4. doi: 10.1093/ageing/24.6.510.
Dysphagia is common after a stroke and is associated with a poor outcome in terms of survival or functional recovery. Percutaneous gastrostomy (PG) provides reliable and safe nutrition for patients with neurological dysphagia in the short term but little is known about the the subsequent outcome in stroke patients. We reviewed the medical records of all stroke patients who had required a PG in four West Yorkshire hospitals over a 30-month period. All patients alive at the time of the study were contacted and functional status was recorded. Forty-one stroke patients had undergone PG and 37 records were obtained. There were 24 men and 13 women with a mean age of 74 years. Thirty-three patients had had a hemiplegia while four patients presented acutely with dysphagia but no hemiplegia (all had cerebral infarcts on CT scan). The timing of PG varied with a median time from stroke of 26 days (range 12-131). Complications include five chest infections ( < 1 week after PG), three local infections, two tubes pulled out and one perforation. Three patients died in the first 5 days after the PG. Thirty-one of the 37 patients had died at the time of the assessment, 21 during the original hospital admission. The median survival from the time of PG was 53 days (range 2-528) with only 12 patients surviving for more than 3 months. Six patients were alive at the time of the study and all but one were severely disabled (mean modified Barthel Index seven). There is no consensus about patients selection or timing of PG and our data should lead to more careful consideration of the risks and benefits of the procedure in stroke patients.
吞咽困难在中风后很常见,并且在生存或功能恢复方面与不良预后相关。经皮胃造瘘术(PG)在短期内为患有神经性吞咽困难的患者提供可靠且安全的营养支持,但对于中风患者的后续结局知之甚少。我们回顾了西约克郡四家医院在30个月期间所有需要进行PG的中风患者的病历。联系了研究时所有存活的患者并记录了其功能状态。41例中风患者接受了PG,获得了37份记录。有24名男性和13名女性,平均年龄74岁。33例患者有偏瘫,4例患者急性出现吞咽困难但无偏瘫(CT扫描均显示脑梗死)。PG的时机各不相同,从中风到进行PG的中位时间为26天(范围12 - 131天)。并发症包括5例胸部感染(PG后<1周)、3例局部感染、2例胃管拔出和1例穿孔。3例患者在PG后的前5天死亡。在评估时,37例患者中有31例死亡,其中21例在原住院期间死亡。从PG时起的中位生存期为53天(范围2 - 528天),只有12例患者存活超过3个月。研究时有6例患者存活,除1例患者外均严重残疾(改良Barthel指数平均为7分)。关于PG的患者选择或时机尚无共识,我们的数据应促使更仔细地考虑该手术在中风患者中的风险和益处。