Lanzarini L, Fetiveau R, Poli A, Diotallevi P, Barberis P, Previtali M
IRCCS-Policlinico S. Matteo, Department of Internal Medicine, University of Pavia, Italy.
Int J Card Imaging. 1995 Dec;11(4):233-40. doi: 10.1007/BF01145191.
Sensitivity of dipyridamole stress echocardiography (DIP-E) has been reported to be less than ideal in particular subsets of patients such as those with less severe extent of coronary artery disease (CAD). To verify if sensitivity could be improved, ATRO (1 mg in 2 minutes) was added at the end of a negative high-dose (0.84 mg/kg over 10 minutes) DIP-E in 61 consecutive patients (58 men, aged 53 +/- 7 years) evaluated for chest pain (33%) or for detection of residual ischemia after acute myocardial infarction (AMI) or previous MI (67%). DIP-E was positive in 28/61 (46%) and negative in 33/61 (54%) patients. Additional echo positivity was obtained in 18/33 (54%) patients after ATRO. Coronary arteriography was normal in 6 patients (10%); 1-vessel CAD was diagnosed in 28 (46%), 2-vessel CAD in 16 (26%) and 3-vessel CAD in 11 (18%) cases. The sensitivity for CAD diagnosis was 49% (27/55) for DIP-E and 84% (46/55) for DIP-E+ATRO (p < 0.001). Specificity was 83% and 80%, respectively. Diagnostic accuracy increased from 52% to 83% (p < 0.001). The better diagnostic accuracy of DIP-E was mainly related to the significant increase in sensitivity of the combined test in patients with 1-vessel CAD (from 46% to 75%) (p < 0.005). At quantitative coronary evaluation, compared to patients with positive DIP-E+ATRO or negative DIP-E+ATRO test, patients with positive DIP-E had a higher mean % diameter stenosis: 80 +/- 13% vs 72 +/- 24% and 65 +/- 36%, respectively. Peak heart rate was significantly higher after the addition of ATRO vs basal and DIP alone in patients with a positive DIP-E+ATRO test. The addition of ATRO to DIP increases diagnostic accuracy of DIP-E particularly in patients with less severe extent of CAD; ATRO may be considered as a useful routine procedure for increasing diagnostic value of DIP-E test.
据报道,双嘧达莫负荷超声心动图(DIP-E)在某些特定患者亚组中的敏感性并不理想,比如那些冠状动脉疾病(CAD)程度较轻的患者。为了验证敏感性是否可以提高,在连续61例(58名男性,年龄53±7岁)因胸痛(33%)或急性心肌梗死(AMI)或既往心肌梗死(MI)后检测残余缺血(67%)而接受评估的患者中,在高剂量(10分钟内0.84mg/kg)DIP-E检查结果为阴性时,于检查结束时添加阿托莫西汀(1mg,2分钟内)。61例患者中,DIP-E检查结果为阳性的有28/61(46%),阴性的有33/61(54%)。添加阿托莫西汀后,33例检查结果为阴性的患者中有18/33(54%)出现额外的超声心动图阳性结果。冠状动脉造影正常的有6例(10%);诊断为单支血管CAD的有28例(46%),双支血管CAD的有16例(26%),三支血管CAD的有11例(18%)。DIP-E对CAD诊断的敏感性为49%(27/55),DIP-E + 阿托莫西汀为84%(46/55)(p < 0.001)。特异性分别为83%和80%。诊断准确性从52%提高到83%(p < 0.001)。DIP-E更好的诊断准确性主要与单支血管CAD患者联合检查敏感性的显著提高有关(从46%提高到75%)(p < 0.005)。在冠状动脉定量评估中,与DIP-E + 阿托莫西汀检查结果为阳性或阴性的患者相比,DIP-E检查结果为阳性的患者平均直径狭窄百分比更高:分别为80±13%、72±24%和65±36%。在DIP-E + 阿托莫西汀检查结果为阳性的患者中,添加阿托莫西汀后峰值心率显著高于基础值和单独使用双嘧达莫时。在DIP中添加阿托莫西汀可提高DIP-E的诊断准确性,尤其是在CAD程度较轻的患者中;阿托莫西汀可被视为提高DIP-E检查诊断价值的一种有用的常规方法。