MacLennan A H, Wilson D H, Taylor A W
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, University of Adelaide, South Australia 5000, Australia.
Lancet. 1996 Mar 2;347(9001):569-73. doi: 10.1016/s0140-6736(96)91271-4.
To determine the prevalence and cost of alternative medicines and alternative practitioner use in an Australian population.
We conducted a representative population survey of persons aged 15 or older living in South Australia, which required 3004 personal interviews. We assessed the rates of use and types of alternative medicine and therapists used by this population in 1993, and correlations with other demographic and medical variables.
The overall use of at least one non-medically prescribed alternative medicine (excluding calcium, iron and prescribed vitamins) was 48.5%. The users were more likely to be perimenopausal females, better educated, have a higher alcohol intake, be of normal weight and more likely to be employed than non-users. 20.3% of respondents had visited at least one alternative practitioner, most commonly chiropractors (15%). The users of alternative practitioners were more likely to be younger, live in the country and be overweight. Women were more likely to consult naturopaths, iridiologists, and reflexologists than men.
Extrapolation of the costs to the Australian population gives a natural expenditure in 1993, for alternative medicines, of $621 million (Australian dollars) and for alternative therapists of $AU309 million per annum. This compares to the $AU360 million of patient contributions for all classes of pharmaceutical drugs purchased in Australia in 1992/93. The public health and economic ramifications of these huge costs are questioned in view of the paucity of sound safety and efficacy data for many of the therapies and products of the alternative medicine industry.
确定澳大利亚人群中使用替代药物及替代疗法从业者的患病率和成本。
我们对居住在南澳大利亚州15岁及以上人群进行了一项具有代表性的人口调查,共进行了3004次个人访谈。我们评估了该人群在1993年使用替代药物和治疗师的比例及类型,以及与其他人口统计学和医学变量的相关性。
至少使用一种非医学处方替代药物(不包括钙、铁和处方维生素)的总体使用率为48.5%。与未使用者相比,使用者更可能是围绝经期女性、受教育程度更高、酒精摄入量更高、体重正常且更可能就业。20.3%的受访者至少拜访过一位替代疗法从业者,最常见的是脊椎按摩师(15%)。替代疗法从业者的使用者更可能年轻、居住在乡村且超重。女性比男性更可能咨询自然疗法医生、虹膜诊断师和反射疗法师。
将成本推算至澳大利亚人群,得出1993年替代药物的自然支出为6.21亿澳元,替代疗法从业者的支出为每年3.09亿澳元。相比之下,1992/93年澳大利亚购买所有类别的药品,患者的缴费为3.6亿澳元。鉴于替代医学行业的许多疗法和产品缺乏可靠的安全性和有效性数据,这些巨额成本对公共卫生和经济的影响受到质疑。