Stone P H, Thompson B, Anderson H V, Kronenberg M W, Gibson R S, Rogers W J, Diver D J, Théroux P, Warnica J W, Nasmith J B, Kells C, Kleiman N, McCabe C H, Schactman M, Knatterud G L, Braunwald E
Cardiovascular Division, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, MA 02115 USA.
JAMA. 1996 Apr 10;275(14):1104-12.
To investigate the natural history and response to treatment of patients with unstable angina or non-Q-wave myocardial infarction (MI).
Inception cohort.
Patients in general community, primary care, or referral hospitals.
All patients with an episode of unstable exertional chest pain or chest pain at rest presumed to be ischemic in origin lasting 5 minutes or more but without persisting ST-segment elevation greater than 30 minutes or the development of Q-waves were identified and enumerated in 18 participating hospitals. A subset of enumerated patients was selected to be followed prospectively using specific sampling strategies that would provide adequate numbers of black, women, and elderly (aged > or = 75 years) patients for comparison with their respective counterparts.
The primary analysis compared the incidence of death or MI at 42 days after entry into the prospective study according to race, sex, and age. Other outcomes considered were recurrent ischemia and the combined outcomes of death, MI, or recurrent ischemia by 42 days after entry.
A total of 8676 admissions with unstable angina or non-Q-wave MI were enumerated and, of these, 3318 patients were selected for the prospective study. The direct adjusted mean age of 3318 patients was 63.8 years. There were 943 blacks and 2375 nonblacks. Compared with nonblacks, blacks were less likely to be treated with intensive anti-ischemic therapy for their qualifying anginal episode and less likely to undergo invasive procedures (risk ratio [RR], 0.65%; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.58 to 0.72; P<.001). However, of those who underwent angiography (45% of blacks and 61% of nonblacks), blacks had less extensive and severe coronary stenoses than nonblacks. The incidence of death and MI was similar for blacks and nonblacks, but blacks had a lower incidence of recurrent ischemia. There were 1678 men and 1640 women. Women were less likely than men to receive intensive anti-ischemic therapy and less likely to undergo coronary angiography (RR, 0.71; 95% CI, 0.65 to 0.78; P<.001). Women had less severe and extensive coronary disease and were less likely to undergo revascularization, yet had a similar risk of experiencing an adverse cardiac event by 6 weeks. There were 2490 patients aged 75 years or less and 828 patients aged more than 75 years. Elderly patients received less aggressive anti-ischemic therapy and were less likely to undergo coronary angiography than their younger counterparts. Elderly patients had more severe and extensive coronary disease but fewer revascularization procedures than younger patients and experienced a much higher incidence of adverse cardiac events both in hospital and by 6 weeks.
Among patients presenting with acute ischemic chest pain without persistent ST-segment elevation, blacks appeared to have less severe coronary disease, received revascularization less frequently, and had less recurrent ischemia compared with nonblacks. Women were also found to have less severe coronary disease and were treated less intensely than men, but experienced similar outcomes. Elderly patients had more severe coronary disease than younger patients on coronary angiography, but were more likely to be treated medically, and they experienced far more adverse outcomes. These data suggest that more aggressive strategies should be directed to those patients with the greatest likelihood of adverse outcomes.
研究不稳定型心绞痛或非Q波心肌梗死(MI)患者的自然病史及对治疗的反应。
起始队列研究。
普通社区、初级保健机构或转诊医院的患者。
在18家参与研究的医院中,识别并统计所有出现发作性不稳定劳力性胸痛或静息性胸痛且推测为缺血性起源、持续5分钟或更长时间但无持续性ST段抬高超过30分钟或Q波形成的患者。使用特定抽样策略前瞻性随访一部分已统计的患者,这些策略将提供足够数量的黑人、女性和老年(年龄≥75岁)患者,以便与各自的对照人群进行比较。
初步分析比较了进入前瞻性研究42天后根据种族、性别和年龄划分的死亡或心肌梗死发生率。还考虑了其他结局,即进入研究42天后的复发性缺血以及死亡、心肌梗死或复发性缺血的综合结局。
共统计了8676例不稳定型心绞痛或非Q波心肌梗死患者,其中3318例患者被选入前瞻性研究。3318例患者的直接校正平均年龄为63.8岁。有943名黑人患者和2375名非黑人患者。与非黑人相比,黑人因符合条件的心绞痛发作接受强化抗缺血治疗的可能性较小,接受侵入性操作的可能性也较小(风险比[RR]为0.65%;95%置信区间[CI]为0.58至0.72;P<0.001)。然而,在接受血管造影的患者中(黑人患者为45%,非黑人患者为61%),黑人的冠状动脉狭窄程度比非黑人轻且范围小。黑人和非黑人的死亡和心肌梗死发生率相似,但黑人的复发性缺血发生率较低。有1678名男性和1640名女性。女性接受强化抗缺血治疗的可能性低于男性,接受冠状动脉造影的可能性也低于男性(RR为0.71;95%CI为0.65至0.78;P<0.001)。女性的冠状动脉疾病严重程度和范围较小,接受血运重建的可能性较小,但在6周时发生不良心脏事件的风险相似。有2490名年龄在75岁及以下的患者和828名年龄超过75岁的患者。老年患者接受的抗缺血治疗不如年轻患者积极,接受冠状动脉造影的可能性也低于年轻患者。老年患者的冠状动脉疾病更严重、范围更广,但血运重建手术比年轻患者少,且在住院期间和6周时发生不良心脏事件的发生率要高得多。
在出现急性缺血性胸痛且无持续性ST段抬高的患者中,与非黑人相比,黑人的冠状动脉疾病似乎较轻,血运重建频率较低,复发性缺血较少。还发现女性的冠状动脉疾病不如男性严重,治疗强度也较低,但结局相似。在冠状动脉造影中,老年患者的冠状动脉疾病比年轻患者更严重,但更可能接受药物治疗,且不良结局更多。这些数据表明,应针对不良结局可能性最大的患者采取更积极的策略。