Aggarwal A, Dutta A K
Kalawati Saran Children's Hospital, New Delhi.
Indian Pediatr. 1995 Jun;32(6):635-9.
Tuberculosis is an important public health problem in developing countries and BCG plays an important role in preventing serious form of the disease in children. BCG induced tuberculin sensitivity is a quantitative characteristic and has been used to compare vaccine efficacy. The standard dose of BCG vaccine is 0.1mg in 1 ml though manufacturers of certain strains of BCG, i.e., Copenhagen 1331 recommend half dose in infants. There are also varying ideas about the optimum time to vaccinate babies and some studies suggest that late vaccination confers a high degree of protection. This study was carried out to evaluate tuberculin sensitivity and side effects following 0.05 ml and 0.1 ml of BCG at birth and 0.1 ml of BCG at 4-6 weeks of age. Two hundred and thirty eight newborns were vaccinated randomly with 0.05 ml and 0.05 ml and 0.1 ml of BCG vaccine (Copenhagen 1331 strain) containing .69 million culturable particles per ml. One hundred and eight infants 4-6 weeks of age were vaccinated with 0.1 ml of BCG. One hundred and fifty five (44.7%) infants were evaluated by Mantoux test using 1TU PPD RT23 10-12 weeks after vaccination and 105 (30.6%) followed up till 6 months for any side effects. No significant difference in mean tuberculin reaction, tuberculin positivity and mean scar size was observed in groups receiving 0.1 ml at birth or 4-6 weeks of age. However, the group receiving 0.05 ml at birth had a significantly lower mean tuberculin reaction, tuberculin positivity and mean scar size. No locoregional side effects were observed. Hence the present practice of giving 0.1 ml of BCG at birth should be continued.
结核病在发展中国家是一个重要的公共卫生问题,卡介苗在预防儿童严重形式的疾病方面发挥着重要作用。卡介苗诱导的结核菌素敏感性是一种定量特征,已被用于比较疫苗效力。卡介苗疫苗的标准剂量是1毫升含0.1毫克,不过某些卡介苗菌株(即哥本哈根1331株)的制造商建议婴儿使用半剂量。关于给婴儿接种疫苗的最佳时间也存在不同观点,一些研究表明延迟接种可提供高度保护。本研究旨在评估出生时接种0.05毫升和0.1毫升卡介苗以及4 - 6周龄接种0.1毫升卡介苗后的结核菌素敏感性和副作用。238名新生儿被随机接种含每毫升69万个可培养颗粒的0.05毫升和0.05毫升以及0.1毫升卡介苗疫苗(哥本哈根1331株)。108名4 - 6周龄的婴儿接种0.1毫升卡介苗。155名(44.7%)婴儿在接种疫苗后10 - 12周使用1TU PPD RT23进行结核菌素试验评估,105名(30.6%)随访至6个月观察任何副作用。在出生时或4 - 6周龄接受0.1毫升的组中,平均结核菌素反应、结核菌素阳性率和平均疤痕大小未观察到显著差异。然而,出生时接受0.05毫升的组平均结核菌素反应、结核菌素阳性率和平均疤痕大小显著较低。未观察到局部副作用。因此,目前在出生时接种0.1毫升卡介苗的做法应继续。