Abrahams J J, Glassberg R M
Department of Diagnostic Radiology, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, CT 06520-8042, USA.
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1996 May;166(5):1219-23. doi: 10.2214/ajr.166.5.8615273.
Periodontal disease may be a frequently unrecognized cause of maxillary sinus disease. The purposes of this study were to determine if maxillary sinus disease is more prevalent in patients with periodontal disease than in an age-and-sex-matched control group and to show radiographically an association of focal maxillary sinus disease with periodontal disease.
Maxillary DentaScans (General Electric Medical Systems, Milwaukee, WI) of 84 patients (168 maxillary sinuses) with periodontal disease were retrospectively evaluated for the simple presence or absence of maxillary sinus disease. This group was compared with an age-and-sex-matched control population of 84 patients who were referred for head or neck CT scans in which the maxillary sinuses (including their inferior aspects) were visualized. For the likelihood of sinus disease in patients compared with controls, an odds ratio and a 95% confidence interval were calculated using the SYSTAT version 5.2 (SYSTAT, Evanston, IL). In the second portion of the study, the subject population alone was graded in the following fashion to establish a causal relationship: grade 0, no sinus disease; grade 1, focal sinus disease not adjacent to periodontal disease (unlikely to be caused by periodontal disease); grade 2, nonfocal sinus disease (complete opacification, air-fluid levels, or diffuse mucoperiosteal thickening; indeterminate cause), and grade 3, focal sinus disease adjacent to periodontal disease (likely to be caused by periodontal disease).
In the subject population--patients with periodontal disease who were referred for DentaScans--100 of 168 (60%) sinuses had sinus disease; in the control population, only 49 of 168 (29%) sinuses had sinus disease. The odds ratio for maxillary sinus disease in the patient population compared with controls was 3.6 (95% confidence interval, 2.3-5.6; p<.0001). The grading results of the subject population in the second portion of the study were grade 0, 68 sinuses (41%); grade 1, four sinuses (2%); grade 2, 32 sinuses (19%); and grade 3, 64 sinuses (38%).
We have demonstrated a twofold increase in maxillary sinus disease in patients with periodontal disease and have shown a causal relationship. Recognition of this relationship may have an impact on the clinical management of patients, particularly those planning implant surgery.
牙周病可能是上颌窦疾病常见的未被认识的病因。本研究的目的是确定上颌窦疾病在牙周病患者中是否比在年龄和性别匹配的对照组中更普遍,并通过影像学显示局限性上颌窦疾病与牙周病之间的关联。
回顾性评估84例牙周病患者(168个上颌窦)的上颌牙片(通用电气医疗系统公司,威斯康星州密尔沃基),以确定是否存在上颌窦疾病。将该组与84例因头部或颈部CT扫描而就诊的年龄和性别匹配的对照人群进行比较,在CT扫描中可观察到上颌窦(包括其下部)。对于患者与对照组中鼻窦疾病的可能性,使用SYSTAT 5.2版软件(SYSTAT公司,伊利诺伊州埃文斯顿)计算比值比和95%置信区间。在研究的第二部分,仅对研究对象人群按以下方式分级以建立因果关系:0级,无鼻窦疾病;1级,与牙周病不相邻的局限性鼻窦疾病(不太可能由牙周病引起);2级,非局限性鼻窦疾病(完全混浊、气液平面或弥漫性黏膜骨膜增厚;病因不确定),3级,与牙周病相邻的局限性鼻窦疾病(可能由牙周病引起)。
在研究对象人群——因牙片检查而就诊的牙周病患者中,168个鼻窦中有100个(60%)患有鼻窦疾病;在对照人群中,168个鼻窦中只有49个(29%)患有鼻窦疾病。患者人群中上颌窦疾病与对照组相比的比值比为3.6(95%置信区间,2.3 - 5.6;p <.0001)。研究第二部分中研究对象人群的分级结果为:0级,68个鼻窦(41%);1级,4个鼻窦(2%);2级,32个鼻窦(19%);3级,64个鼻窦(38%)。
我们已证明牙周病患者上颌窦疾病增加了两倍,并显示出因果关系。认识到这种关系可能会对患者尤其是计划进行种植手术的患者的临床管理产生影响。