Porter D H, Rosen M P, Skillman J J, Sheiman R G, Kent K C, Kim D
Department of Radiology, Beth Israel Hospital, Boston, MA, 02215, USA.
J Vasc Surg. 1996 Apr;23(4):554-67. doi: 10.1016/s0741-5214(96)80033-4.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the outcomes of our 6-year experience with directional atherectomy used for treatment of stenoses in infrainguinal vein grafts.
From March 1988 to April 1994, 52 directional atherectomy procedures were undertaken in 42 patients to treat 67 stenoses in 44 vein grafts. Follow-up consisted of periodic physical examinations and graft surveillance; ankle/brachial indexes, pulse volume recordings, and color-flow duplex ultrasonography. Follow-up angiography (n = 18) was performed for recurrent symptoms, reproducible drop in ankle/brachial index of greater than 0.15, a twofold to threefold focal increase in peak systolic velocity, or incidentally during evaluation of the opposite leg.
Forty-nine of 52 (94%) procedures were technically successful. In two the residual diameter stenosis was greater than 30%, and in one atherectomy could not be performed. Complications were minor in six (11%) and major in three (6%): two acute graft occlusions and one delayed pseudoaneurysm at the atherectomy site. There were no deaths at 30 days. With a mean follow-up of 21 +/- 18 months, 36 of 44 grafts (82%) remained patent without restenosis; 6 others were patent but considered "failed"--5 (11%) with restenosis, 1 with a pseudoaneurysm; and 2 grafts (5%) occluded. Clinically 33 of 44 extremities (75%) were asymptomatic during follow-up. Claudication improved in five, recurred in three, and was unchanged in one. There was one below-knee amputation. Life-table analysis including all 52 procedures reveals cumulative primary atherectomy patency rates for the 44 grafts of 82%, 78%, and 78%, respectively, at 1, 2, and 3 years after atherectomy, and 86%, 83%, and 83% for the 67 individual stenoses treated.
Directional atherectomy of vein graft stenoses has high technical and clinical success rates, acceptably low morbidity rates, and offers better sustained patency rates than balloon angioplasty. Its long-term patency rate seems to approach that of surgical vein patch angioplasty.
本研究旨在评估我们应用定向旋切术治疗股腘静脉移植血管狭窄6年的经验结果。
从1988年3月至1994年4月,对42例患者进行了52次定向旋切术,以治疗44条静脉移植血管中的67处狭窄。随访包括定期体格检查和移植血管监测;踝/肱指数、脉搏容积记录和彩色血流双功超声检查。对复发症状、踝/肱指数可重复下降大于0.15、收缩期峰值流速局部增加两倍至三倍或在对侧下肢评估时偶然发现的情况进行随访血管造影(n = 18)。
52例手术中有49例(94%)技术成功。2例残余直径狭窄大于30%,1例无法进行旋切术。并发症轻微的有6例(11%),严重的有3例(6%):2例急性移植血管闭塞和1例在旋切部位的迟发性假性动脉瘤。30天内无死亡病例。平均随访21±18个月,44条移植血管中有36条(82%)保持通畅无再狭窄;另外6条通畅但被认为“失败”——5条(11%)发生再狭窄,1条有假性动脉瘤;2条移植血管(5%)闭塞。临床上,44条肢体中有33条(75%)在随访期间无症状。间歇性跛行改善的有5例,复发的有3例,无变化的有1例。有1例膝下截肢。包括所有52例手术的生存分析显示,44条移植血管在旋切术后1年、2年和3年的累积初次旋切通畅率分别为82%、78%和78%,所治疗的67处狭窄的通畅率分别为86%、83%和83%。
静脉移植血管狭窄的定向旋切术具有较高的技术和临床成功率、可接受的低发病率,并且与球囊血管成形术相比具有更好的持续通畅率。其长期通畅率似乎接近手术静脉补片血管成形术。